论母的注释·8. 时限物解说注释
小学根本学·小学新复注 · 92 段
8. 时限物解说注释巴利
8. Kālikaniddesavaṇṇanā
84 所谓“有时限的”,是指日中、后夜、七天、尽形寿这些时段内可以受用的东西,也就是所有被称为嚼食、啖食、饮品的食物。不过按数量来分,它们有四种。那么,这些食物在还没被接受时,是不是单凭自身性质就能得到“有时限”这个称呼,还是要另有条件呢?回答说“已接受”。意思是:只有已经被接受之后,它们才能获得日限物等“有时限”的称呼,否则不行。现在就用“日限物”等来说明它们。其中,从黎明到正午这段时间内可以受用,所以时限是到正午为止,这叫日限物,比如糗粑之类的食物。过了正午就不能再吃了;为了知道时限的界限,可以立一根时限柱,或者换个时间再吃。到夜晚后分这段时间内可以受用,所以时限是夜分,这叫夜分限物。接受之后可以存放七天,所以时限是七天,这叫七日限物。除了水以外,其余一切已接受的东西,尽形寿都可以保留,有因缘时就受用,所以时限是尽形寿,这叫尽形寿物。巴利
84.Kālikāti majjhanhikapacchimayāmasattāhayāvajīvappavattisaṅkhāto kālo etesamatthīti kālikā, sabbepi khajjabhojjaleyyapeyyasaṅkhātā atthā. Te pana gaṇanaparicchedato cattāro honti. Kiṃ te appaṭiggahitāpi sabhāveneva kālikavohāraṃ labhanti, udāhu aññathāpīti āha ‘‘paṭiggahitā’’ti, paṭiggahitāyeva te yāvakālikādi kālikavohāralābhino, no aññathāti adhippāyo. Idāni te dasseti ‘‘yāvakālika’’ntiādinā. Tattha aruṇuggamanato yāva ṭhitamajjhanhiko, tāva paribhuñjitabbattā yāva majjhanhikasaṅkhāto kālo assāti yāvakālikaṃ, piṭṭhakhādanīyādikaṃ vatthu, ṭhitamajjhanhikato paṭṭhāya taṃ paribhuñjituṃ na sakkā, kālaparicchedajānanatthaṃ kālatthambho vā yojetabbo, kālantare vā bhattakiccaṃ kātabbaṃ. Yāva rattiyā pacchimasaṅkhāto yāmo, tāva paribhuñjitabbato yāmo kālo assāti yāmakālikaṃ. Paṭiggahetvā sattāhaṃ nidhetabbato sattāho kālo assāti sattāhakālikaṃ. Ṭhapetvā udakaṃ avasesaṃ sabbampi paṭiggahitaṃ yāvajīvaṃ pariharitvā sati paccaye paribhuñjitabbato jīvassa yattako paricchedo yāvajīvaṃ, taṃ assa atthīti yāvajīvikaṃ.
难道不像在其他地方那样吗?在“尽形寿”这个说法里,如果没有时间方面的限定,怎么能成立“四种时限物”呢?这是成立的,因为对善逝们来说,并不存在脱离诸蕴而独立的时间;而被称为“命”的命根,本来就包含在诸蕴之中,所以那命也就是时间。难道这里说的不就是以“时分食”等所说明的那些,才被称为“时限物”吗?是不是应该叫“诸时限物”呢?不应这样理解。“时分食”等说法是就其所关联的事物而说的,而“时限物”则是依据共通性与意义和语词关联而说的,所以并不矛盾。巴利
Nanu ca aññattha viya ‘‘yāvajīvika’’nti ettha kālasutiyā abhāve kathaṃ ‘‘cattāro kālikā’’ti yujjatīti? Yujjati, sogatānaṃ khandhavinimuttasseva kālassābhāvato jīvasaṅkhātassa jīvitindriyassa khandhasaṅgahitattā sopi kāloyevāti. Nanu cettha ‘‘yāvakālika’’ntiādinā niddiṭṭhāneva ‘‘kālikā’’ti vuttāni, ‘‘kālikānī’’ti vattabbaṃ siyāti? Nedamevaṃ viññeyyaṃ, ‘‘kālika’’ntiādīni vatthusambandhena vuttāni, ‘‘kālikā’’ti pana sāmaññantaravasena atthasaddasambandhena vuttanti natthi virodhoti.
85 现在用“粉”等来说明日限物。其中,粉、根、果,就是粉嚼食、根嚼食和果嚼食。这里先说七种谷物、随顺谷物的作物以及其他谷物的粉,还有波罗蜜、沙罗树、菩提树、芒果、枣椰、多罗等的粉——在各地当作日常食物,能用来完成咀嚼吞咽的粉,就是粉嚼食。像“没洗的多罗粉、乳藤粉”等这些被列举出来的,数量多到数不清,但它们的共同特征就是能完成咀嚼吞咽的作用。就算再多说,也还是落在这个特征上,所以这里不再展开。其他各类也都是同样的道理。甘蔗、红米等的根,是根嚼食。波罗蜜、沙罗树、椰子等的果实,是果嚼食。“嚼食”指的是糖球、蜜糕等由主谷与杂谷制成的嚼食。“牛味”指的是牛奶、酸奶、酪浆这些从牛身上来的味道。“谷食”指的是随顺谷物的饭、炒粉、粥等所说的食物。不过复注里说“随顺谷物和七种谷物以及五种食物”,这并不合理,因为单独把谷物拿出来没有意义;如果真有意义,那通过取“果”就已经能把它们包含进去了。巴利
85. Idāni tesu ‘‘piṭṭha’’ntiādinā yāvakālikaṃ dasseti. Tattha piṭṭhaṃ mūlaṃ phalanti piṭṭhakhādanīyaṃ mūlakhādanīyaṃ phalakhādanīyañca . Tattha sattannaṃ tāva dhaññānaṃ dhaññānulomānaṃ aparaṇṇānañca piṭṭhaṃ panasalabujaambāṭakadhotatālapiṭṭhādikañceti tesu tesu janapadesu pakatiāhāravasena 03 manussānaṃ khādanīyabhojanīyakiccasādhakaṃ piṭṭhaṃ piṭṭhakhādanīyaṃ. ‘‘Adhotaṃ tālapiṭṭhaṃ khīravallipiṭṭha’’ntiādinā gaṇiyamānānaṃ gaṇanāya anto natthi, khādanīyabhojanīyakiccasādhakabhāvoyeva panetesaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ, subahuṃ vatvāpi imasmiṃyeva lakkhaṇe ṭhātabbanti na vitthārayāma. Evaṃ sabbattha. Tambakataṇḍuleyyādimūlaṃ mūlakhādanīyaṃ. Panasalabujanāḷikerādiphalaṃ phalakhādanīyaṃ. Khajjanti sakkhalimodakādipubbaṇṇāparaṇṇamayaṃ khādanīyañca. Gorasoti khīradadhitakkasaṅkhāto gunnaṃ raso ca. Dhaññabhojananti sānulomānaṃ dhaññānaṃ odanasattukummāsasaṅkhātabhojanañca. Ṭīkāyaṃ pana ‘‘sānulomāni sattadhaññāni ca pañcavidhabhojanañcā’’ti vuttaṃ, taṃ na yuttaṃ, dhaññānaṃ visuṃ gahaṇe payojanābhāvā, payojanasambhave ca phalaggahaṇeneva tesaṃ gahaṇasambhavato.
“粥、汤等”是指粥和汤,以这些为起始的,这些就是时分食,应当这样连接理解。这里用“等”这个字,包含了被称为鱼和肉的、从谷物食物中剩下的食物,以及从粉食、根食、果食中剩下的块茎嚼食、芦根嚼食等。其中,长的如藕块茎等,圆的如莲藕等,属于块茎嚼食;莲根等以及与之相似的伊罗迦根等,属于芦根嚼食;多罗树等树上称为棕榈嫩芽的顶端部分,属于顶嚼食;甘蔗茎等,以及青莲等的茎干等,属于茎嚼食;红蓝等的叶子,属于叶嚼食;只有甘蔗皮这一种有味道的部分,属于皮嚼食;红蓝、合欢花等,属于花嚼食;面包果核、波罗蜜核等,属于核嚼食。巴利
Yāgusūpappabhutayoti yāgu ca sūpañca, taṃ pabhuti yesaṃ teti ete yāvakālikā hontīti sambandho. Ettha ca pabhuti-saddena macchamaṃsasaṅkhātaṃ dhaññabhojanato avasiṭṭhaṃ bhojanañca piṭṭhamūlaphalakhādanīyato avasiṭṭhaṃ kandakhādanīyaṃ, muḷālakhādanīyādiñca saṅgaṇhāti. Tesu dīgho ca bhisakandādi vaṭṭo ca uppalakaṇḍādi kandakhādanīyaṃ, padumamūlādi ca taṃsadisaṃ erakamūlādi ca muḷālakhādanīyaṃ, tālādīnaṃ kaḷīrasaṅkhātā matthakā matthakakhādanīyaṃ, ucchukkhandhādayo nīluppalādīnaṃ daṇḍakkhandhakādi khandhakhādanīyaṃ, tambakataṇḍuleyyādīnaṃ paṇṇaṃ pattakhādanīyaṃ, ucchutacova eko saraso tacakhādanīyaṃ, tambakasiggupupphādi pupphakhādanīyaṃ, labujaṭṭhipanasaṭṭhiādikaṃ aṭṭhikhādanīyaṃ.
86 以“蜜”等语,指出夜分药。蜜、葡萄、睡莲根、有核芭蕉、香蕉、芒果和阎浮,这是并列复合词。葡萄在表示果实的意思时也作阴性,其余果名作中性;“阎浮”是另一个表示果实的中性词。由它们所生的蜜饮等,即蜜所生……中略……阎浮所生,这些与粗食一起,作为饮,应这样连接。其中,所谓蜜所生之饮,是把葡萄的果味汁与水混合后制成的饮。若由自己制作,食前无论有肉无肉都可以。但若从尚未受具足戒的人那里得到,在食前接受,食前即使有肉也可以;食后则只有无肉才可以。这个规则对一切饮都适用。所谓葡萄所生之饮,是把葡萄在水中压碎后制成的饮。同样,其余各种饮应按照各自的情况来了知。睡莲根,就是红莲等的睡莲根。有核芭蕉,是有核的芭蕉果。香蕉,则是无核的。这八种饮,冷的和日晒的都可以,但火煮的则不可以,所以说“非火所热”。巴利
86.‘‘Madhū’’tiādinā yāmakālikaṃ dasseti. Madhu ca muddikā ca sālūkañca cocañca mocañca ambañca jambu cāti dvando. Muddikā phalepi itthiyaṃ, phale sesā napuṃsake, ‘‘jambu’’ iti phalavācī napuṃsakasaddantaraṃ, tato jātaṃ madhupānādi madhu…pe… jambujaṃ, tañca phārusañca pānakanti yojanā. Tattha madhujaṃ pānaṃ nāma muddikānaṃ jātirasaṃ udakasambhinnaṃ katvā katapānaṃ. Taṃ attanā kataṃ purebhattameva sāmisaṃ nirāmisampi vaṭṭati. Anupasampannehi kataṃ labhitvā pana purebhattaṃ paṭiggahitaṃ purebhattaṃ sāmisampi vaṭṭati, pacchābhattaṃ pana nirāmisameva vaṭṭati. Esa nayo sabbapānesu. Muddikajaṃ pānaṃ nāma muddikānaṃ udake madditvā katapānaṃ. Tathā sesapānāni yathānurūpaṃ veditabbāni, sālūkaṃ rattuppalādīnaṃ sālūkaṃ. Cocaṃ aṭṭhikakadaliphalaṃ. Mocaṃ anaṭṭhikaṃ. Imāni aṭṭha pānāni sītānipi ādiccapākānipi vaṭṭanti, aggipākāni pana na vaṭṭanti. Tenāha ‘‘nāggisantatta’’nti.
87-8 其余那些藤、草、酸橙、木苹果、罗望子等小果所制的饮料,只属于八种饮料类。因此说“与随顺谷物一起的,除了果生汁”。对于后面将要说的“花汁”等,应当知道它们与“用冷水浸泡或以日晒煮熟的,是时分药”这句话相关联。棕榈、椰子、波罗蜜、面包果、葫芦、南瓜、蒲萨果、黄瓜、甜瓜果,这九种大果,以及一切其他菜蔬,都随顺七种谷物,所以连同随顺的一起称为“与随顺”。与随顺谷物所生的汁,是时分药。“与随顺谷物”被理解为果实。在果经中本应说“其余果所生”,因为意思已经明了,所以没有说。“除了蜜花”就是除去蜜花。“熟达伽”是指由已熟的、属于时分药的达伽所生的汁。冷水就是冷水,像在乳中浸泡于冷水一样,所以是依主释。“阿迪咤”这个词用在热力上,所以“于阿迪咤中煮熟”是有财释。巴利
87-8. Avasesāni pana vettatintiṇikamātuluṅgakapitthakaramandādikhuddakaphalapānāni aṭṭhapānagatikāneva. Tenāha ‘‘sānulomāni dhaññāni, ṭhapetvā phalajo raso’’ti. Ekassa pana vakkhamānānañca ‘‘puppharaso’’tiādīnaṃ ‘‘sītodamadditādiccapāko vā yāmakāliko’’ti iminā sambandho veditabbo. Tālanāḷikerapanasalabujaalābukumbhaṇḍapussaphalatipusaeḷālukaphalānīti nava mahāphalāni, sabbañca aparaṇṇaṃ sattadhaññāni anulomentīti saha anulomehīti sānulomāni. Sānulomadhaññānaṃ pana raso yāvakāliko. ‘‘Sānulomāni dhaññānī’’ti phalāni viññāyanti. Phalasutiyā ‘‘sesaphalajo’’ti vattabbe gamyamānattā na vuttaṃ. Madhukapupphamaññatrāti madhukapupphaṃ ṭhapetvā. Pakkaḍākajanti pakkehi yāvakālikehi ḍākehi jātaṃ rasaṃ. Sītamudakaṃ sītodaṃ, khīrode viya sītode madditoti tappuriso. Ādicca-saddo ātape vattati upacāratoti ādicce pāko yassāti samāso.
89 用“酥油”等词来说明七日药。其中,所谓七日药,就是前面所说的酥油等,这些属于七日药。现在用“酥油”等词来分别说明酥油等。其中,对于那些允许吃牛、水牛等肉的人来说,他们的酥油就叫作酥油,因此用“酥油”等词来说明酥油的特征。即使是不允许吃的肉所制的酥油,在允许的情况下,因为下文将会说到超过七天就犯恶作罪,所以这里只是为了显示舍堕的对象,才说“他们的肉没有被禁止”。因为在乳等当中,对他们来说并没有所谓不允许的情况。由于生酥和酥油相似,所以没有另外单独说明生酥的特征。把酥油团放在上面,然后布施冷粥,凡是还没有和粥混合的,属于七日药;如果已经混合了,经过日晒煮熟并过滤,或者加入乳再煮的油,在这些当中,生酥叫作新提取的,而由它制成的才是酥油。巴利
89. Sattāhakālikaṃ dasseti ‘‘sappī’’tiādinā. Tattha sattāhakālikāti yathāvuttāni sappiādīni sattāhakālikāni. Idāni sappiādīni vibhajati ‘‘sappī’’tiādinā. Tattha yesaṃ gomahiṃ sādīnaṃ maṃsaṃ kappati, tesaṃ sappi sappi nāmāti ‘‘sappī’’tiādinā sappilakkhaṇamāha. Akappiyamaṃsasappinopi kappiyasambhave tattha sattāhātikkame dukkaṭassa vakkhamānattā nissaggiyavatthumeva cettha dassetuṃ ‘‘yesaṃ maṃsamavārita’’nti vuttaṃ. Khīrādīsu hi tesamakappiyaṃ nāma natthi. Navanītassa sappisadisatāya navanītalakkhaṇaṃ visuṃ na vuttaṃ. Upari sappipiṇḍaṃ ṭhapetvā sītalapāyāsaṃ denti, yaṃ pāyāsena asaṃsaṭṭhaṃ, taṃ sattāhakālikaṃ, missitaṃ pana ādiccapākaṃ katvā parissāvitaṃ, tathā khīraṃ pakkhipitvā pakkatelampi, tesu navanītaṃ nāma navuddhaṭaṃ. Tena kataṃ pana sappi.
90 芝麻、油脂、蓖麻、蜜树、芥子,这是并列复合词。由这些原料产生的东西,从外在含义来说,就叫作油,意思就是油。小苍蝇、小蜜蝇和熊蜂合称小蜂,因为是小生物,所以用中性单数。酿蜜的,就是酿蜜蜂,它们就是苍蝇,叫酿蜜苍蝇;小蜂就是酿蜜苍蝇,这是持业释。由它们酿成的蜜,就叫作蜜,意思就是蜜。不过在复注里,把酿蜜者这个词单独分开解释后说,在树枝上酿蜜的,叫酿蜜苍蝇。蜜膜或蜜渣如果被蜜涂过,就只算蜜这一类。而类似土蜂与蟋蟀的树脂状渗出物的蜜,则是尽形寿药。无渣的汁液等,叫作汁等。用等字包括糖浆等,那是甘蔗制品。熟的,是指不依赖其他基础而直接成熟的,糖浆就叫作糖浆,意思就是这样。但用冷水做的蜜花糖浆,只算糖浆一类。芒果糖浆等是时分药。以上所说的酥等,午前可以掺着食物一起受用,但从午后开始,以及午后接受的那些,要储存七天,以不掺食物的方式受用。巴利
90. Tilā ca vasā ca eraṇḍāni ca madhukāni ca sāsapā cāti dvando. Tehi sambhavo yassāti bāhirattho, taṃ telaṃ nāmāti attho. Khuddā khuddamadhumakkhikā ca bhamarā ca khuddabhamaraṃ, khuddajantukattā napuṃsakekavacanaṃ. Madhuṃ karontīti madhukariyo, tā eva makkhikā madhukarimakkhikā, khuddabhamarameva madhukarimakkhikāti kammadhārayo. Tāhi kataṃ madhu madhu nāmāti attho. Ṭīkāyaṃ pana visuṃ madhukarī-saddaṃ vikappetvā ‘‘daṇḍakesu madhukarā madhukarimakkhikā nāmā’’ti vuttaṃ. Madhupaṭalaṃ vā madhusitthakaṃ vā sace madhunā makkhitaṃ, madhugatikameva. Tumbalakānaṃ cīrikānañca niyyāsasadisaṃ madhu pana yāvajīvikaṃ. Raso nikkasaṭo ādi yassā sā rasādi. Ādi-saddena phāṇitādīnaṃ gahaṇaṃ, sā ucchuvikati. Pakkāti avatthukapakkā vā, phāṇitaṃ phāṇitaṃ nāmāti attho. Sītūdakena katamadhukapupphaphāṇitaṃ pana phāṇitagatikameva. Ambaphāṇitādīni yāvakālikāni. Etāni yathāvuttāni sappiādīni purebhattaṃ sāmisaparibhogenāpi, pacchābhattato paṭṭhāya pana tāni ca pacchābhattaṃ paṭiggahitāni ca sattāhaṃ nidahitvā nirāmisaparibhogena paribhuñjitabbāni.
91 91. 现在,为了说明依据特别允许而区分出来的已煮熟之物,接着为了说明酥等,所以说了“有基础”等话。其中,午前是自己亲手做的,或者由自己本人做。“或”这个字表示也可以由别人做。非人的(脂肪),就是不含人类脂肪的。脂肪,是指熊等不允许的众生身上的脂肪,以及猪等允许的众生身上的脂肪。有基础而煮熟的,属于七日药,这是剩下的部分。“有基础煮熟”就是把有基础的东西煮熟。这里的意思是:如果在午前接受脂肪后煮熟、滤出油,应当以无食物的方式受用七天。如果是别人做好、在午前接受的,那么午前即使掺有食物也可以;从午后开始就只能无食物受用,否则就犯恶作。在指称结果时以原因作代称,所以这里用“脂肪”来指油本身,但脂肪只是时分药。巴利
91. Idāni odissa anuññātavasāya pākato vibhāgaṃ dassetvā tato sappiādīnaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘savatthū’’tiādimāha. Tattha purebhattaṃ sāmaṃ vā attanā eva. Vā-saddena parehi vā. Amānusā manussavasārahitā. Vasā acchādīnaṃ akappiyānaṃ, sūkarādīnaṃ kappiyānañca sattānaṃ vasā. Savatthupakkā sattāhakālikā hotīti seso. Savatthupakkāti savatthukaṃ katvā pakkā. Ayamettha adhippāyo – sace pana vasaṃ purebhattaṃ paṭiggahetvā pacitvā telaṃ parissāvitaṃ sattāhāni nirāmisaparibhogena paribhuñjitabbaṃ. Atha parehi kataṃ purebhattaṃ paṭiggahitaṃ, purebhattaṃ sāmisampi vaṭṭati, pacchābhattato paṭṭhāya nirāmisameva, no ce, dukkaṭaṃ hotīti. Kāriye kāraṇopacārena panettha ‘‘vasā’’ti telameva vuttaṃ, vasā pana yāvakālikāva.
复注里则是依据“有人说,脂肪不存在七日时药的情况”这句话,接着又说“这应当审察”,因此对脂肪是否属于七日时药提出了怀疑。这里应当审察什么呢?世尊在允许药时说过:“诸比丘,那些适合病比丘的药,就是酥油、生酥、油、蜜、糖浆,接受这些后,最多储存七天受用。”这里只说了酥油等的七日时性。在药犍度中也说:“诸比丘,我允许接受这五种药后,在时和非时受用。”说了这五种就是“药”之后,对油又明确说:“诸比丘,我允许脂肪药:熊脂、鱼脂、鳄鱼脂、猪脂、驴脂,在时接受、在时煮熟、在时混合,以用油的方式受用。”在药学处注疏中,以“除了人脂,其他任何脂肪”等说明了脂肪油的规定,然后注疏师说“其他时分时药的基础不允许煮”,由此表明这里的含义是:除了时分时药中的脂肪,其他时分时药的基础不允许煮,所以脂肪被理解为“只是时分时药”。这里有什么微细的道理呢?巴利
Ṭīkāyaṃ pana vasāya ‘‘sattāhakālike āgataṭṭhānaṃ natthīti vadantī’’ti vatvā ‘‘taṃ upaparikkhitabba’’nti vasāya sattāhakālikattamāsaṃkiyaṃ vuttaṃ. Kimettha upaparikkhitabbaṃ? Bhesajjaṃ anujānatā bhagavatā ‘‘yāni kho pana tāni gilānānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ paṭisāyanīyāni bhesajjāni, seyyathidaṃ – sappi navanītaṃ telaṃ madhu phāṇitaṃ, tāni paṭiggahetvā sattāhaparamaṃ sannidhikārakaṃ paribhuñjitabbānī’’ti (pārā. 622) sappiādīnameva sattāhakālikattaṃ vuttaṃ. Bhesajjakkhandhakepi ‘‘anujānāmi, bhikkhave, tāni pañca bhesajjāni paṭiggahetvā kālepi vikālepi paribhuñjitu’’nti (mahāva. 260) tāni pañceva ‘‘bhesajjānī’’ti vatvā telaṃ niyamato ‘‘anujānāmi, bhikkhave, vasāni bhesajjāni acchavasaṃ macchavasaṃ susukāvasaṃ sūkaravasaṃ gadrabhavasaṃ kāle paṭiggahitaṃ kāle nippakkaṃ kāle saṃsaṭṭhaṃ telaparibhogena paribhuñjitu’’nti (mahāva. 262) vuttaṃ. Bhesajjasikkhāpadaṭṭhakathāyañca (kaṅkhā. aṭṭha. bhesajjasikkhāpadavaṇṇanā) ‘‘ṭhapetvā manussavasaṃ aññaṃ yaṃ kiñci vasa’’ntiādinā vasātelassa vidhānaṃ dassetvā ‘‘aññesaṃ yāvakālikavatthūnaṃ vatthuṃ pacituṃ na vaṭṭatiyevā’’ti vadatā aṭṭhakathācariyena yāvakālikesu vasaṃ ṭhapetvā aññesaṃ yāvakālikavatthūnaṃ vatthuṃ pacituṃ na vaṭṭatīti ayamettha attho dīpitoti vasā ‘‘yāvakālikāyevā’’ti viññāyatīti ko ettha sukhumo nayoti.
除脂肪油以外,其他人所拥有的其他时分药所依之物——也就是那些被称为时分药的乳等——不作煮制。这就是此处的关联。此处的意趣是:譬如为了七日受用,可以在适当的时间接受脂肪、在适当的时间煮制;但作为酥油等所依的乳等时分药则不然——即使为了七日受用,在适当的时间煮制也不可以。因为若接受了那些乳等之后自己做成酥油等,从午后起就不可以用,这是由于它连同所依一同被接受了;掺有食物也不可以用,因为是自己煮的;即使在午前也不可以用,因为它已从时分药的所依中分离出来。然而若是别人做成的,午前即使掺有食物也可以用,因为不是自己煮的。至于尽形寿药,如芥子、蜜树、蓖麻、骨头,为了制油而接受后,当天做成的油属于七日药,第二天做成的可以六天,如此直到第七天做成的只允许当天;黎明升起时就犯舍堕,第八天不可吞服,这和用任何已接受之物做成的情况相同。为了制油而接受的芥子等,超过七天则犯恶作。已经做成的酥油或生酥,在适当时间或非适当时间接受后煮是可以的。但如果当天午前有食物混合,则不可以,因为混合后可能成为时分药而且是自己煮的;如果没有食物混合,则七日药也可以。巴利
Aññesaṃ vasātelato paresaṃ yāvakālikavatthūnaṃ yesaṃ tesaṃ yāvakālikavatthūnaṃ sappiādīnaṃ vatthuṃ yāvakālikasaṅkhātaṃ khīrādikaṃ na paceti sambandho. Ayamettha adhippāyo – yathā sattāhaparibhogatthāya vasaṃ kāle paṭiggahetvā kāle pacituṃ vaṭṭati, na evaṃ sappiādīnaṃ vatthubhūtaṃ khīrādiyāvakālikaṃ, taṃ pana sattāhaparibhogatthāya kālepi na vaṭṭati. Tāni hi yadi taṃ paṭiggahetvā sayaṃ katāni, pacchābhattato paṭṭhāya na vaṭṭanti savatthukappaṭiggahitattā, sāmisaṃ na vaṭṭanti sāmaṃpakkattā, purebhattampi na vaṭṭanti yāvakālikavatthuto vivecitattā. Parehi katāni pana purebhattaṃ sāmisampi vaṭṭanti attanā apakkattā. Yāvajīvikāni tu sāsapamadhukaeraṇḍaaṭṭhīni telakaraṇatthaṃ paṭiggahetvā tadaheva kataṃ telaṃ sattāhakālikaṃ, dutiyadivase kataṃ chāhaṃ vaṭṭati, evaṃ yāva sattamadivase kataṃ tadaheva vaṭṭati, uggate aruṇe nissaggiyaṃ , aṭṭhame divase anajjhoharaṇīyaṃ, uggahitena yena kenaci vatthunā katasadisaṃ hoti. Telatthāya paṭiggahitasāsapādīnaṃ sattāhātikkamena dukkaṭaṃ. Nibbattitaṃ sappi vā navanītaṃ vā kālepi vikālepi paṭiggahetvā pacituṃ vaṭṭati. Taṃ pana tadahu purebhattampi sāmisaṃ na vaṭṭati, saṃsaggato yāvakālikampi sāmaṃpakkaṃ siyāti nirāmisaṃ pana sattāhampi vaṭṭati.
92 现在用“姜黄”等词来说明尽形寿药。在这里,即使按照“所谓姜黄,就是尼萨”这类说法来讲述,因为是同义词的表达,可能会让人迷惑,所以我们不打算用那种说法造成太大的混乱,因此这些只应该依据教导本身来理解。其中,“姜黄”这个词是通过增加随韵来说的。但从引申用法来说,根等事物是用姜黄等词来表达的。那些姜黄等词,有些只是阴性。穆拉帕拉与瓦卡塔……乃至……跋达木达与阿提维萨,这是词的分段。用“五根”这个词,包含了小五根和大五根。用“等”字,包含了瓦迦利根、迦拉提等。巴利
92. Idāni ‘‘haliddi’’ntiādinā yāvajīvikaṃ dasseti. Tattha ‘‘haliddi nāma nisā’’tiādinā vuccamānepi pariyāyavacane sammoho siyāti na taṃvacanena bhusaṃ sammohayissāma, tasmā tāni upadesatova veditabbāni. Tattha ‘‘haliddi’’nti binduāgamena vuttaṃ. Upacārena tu mūlādīni haliddādisaddena vuttāni. Tā haliddādayo keci itthiliṅgāyeva. Mūlaphale vacattañca…pe… bhaddamuttañca ativisāti padacchedo. Pañcamūla-saddena cūḷapañcamūlamahāpañcamūlāni gahitāni. Ādi-saddena vajakalimūle jaraṭṭhanti evamādīnaṃ saṅgaho.
93-5 果提帕拉,就是人们所说的马达那果。三种果被它包含在内,所以叫提帕拉。伊兰达咖等中的“等”字,包含了迦提树等。与苏拉萨等的叶相关联。以“等”字包含阿索咖等。“苏贝亚叶”是指适合做汤的叶,比如坦巴咖、坦杜勒亚等。除了甘蔗汁渣以外的一切汁液,以及除了无汁甘蔗皮等以外的一切皮,这是相关联的。其中,兴古、咖尼咖拉汁等一切汁液,叫作“汁”。无汁甘蔗皮等一切皮,叫作“皮”。盐是指海盐等。金属是指铁、铜等。石是指黑石等。巴利
93-5.Goṭṭhaphalanti madanaphalanti vadantīti. Tīṇi phalāni yassaṃ saṅgahitaṃ sā tiphalā. Eraṇḍakādīnanti ādi-saddena jātirukkhādīnaṃ gahaṇaṃ. Sulasādīnaṃ paṇṇanti sambandho. Ādi-saddena asokādīnaṃ gahaṇaṃ. Sūpeyyapaṇṇanti tambakataṇḍuleyyādisūpayoggapaṇṇaṃ. Ucchuniyyāsaṃ ṭhapetvā sabbo niyyāso ca sarasaṃ ucchujaṃ tacañca ṭhapetvā sabbo taco cāti sambandho. Tattha hiṅgukaṇikāraniyyāsādi sabbo niyyāso nāma. Nirasaucchutacādi sabbo taco nāma. Loṇaṃ sāmuddādi. Lohaṃ ayatambādi. Silā kāḷasilādi.
96 “纯净蜂蜡”是指没有用蜂蜜涂抹过的蜂蜡。用蜂蜜涂抹过的蜂蜡,就属于七日药。“以及任何善加煅烧的东西”:是指没有烧坏、保持善加煅烧的任何东西。“各种变坏的东西等等”:变坏的东西指粪、土、尿、灰等,“等等”表示还包括这一类中的其他东西;这些种类就是它的分别,这是从外在含义来说的,指的就是那些东西。与“任何”一词相连。这里用“等等”一词所包括的,应当这样理解:在可吃的块茎类中,如乳树胶等;在可吃的根类中,如姜黄、生姜根等;在可吃的顶芽类中,如姜黄、生姜、咖离拉等;在可吃的茎类中,如莲叶茎等;在可吃的花类中,如瞻波咖花等;在可吃的核类中,如蜜核、伊兰达、芥子等;在可吃的粉类中,如未熟椰子粉等。巴利
96.Suddhasitthanti madhunā amakkhitaṃ. Madhumakkhitaṃ pana sattāhakālikaṃ. Yañca kiñci sujhāpitanti dujjhāpitaṃ akatvā sujjhāpitaṃ yaṃ kiñci ca. Vikaṭādippabhedanti vikaṭaṃ gūthamattikāmuttachārikāsaṅkhātaṃ ādi yassa, so pabhedo yassāti bāhirattho, taṃ. Yaṃ kiñci cāti sambandho. Ettha pana ādi-saddena kandakhādanīye khīrakākolādayo, muḷālakhādanīye haliddisiṅgiveramūlādayo, matthakakhādanīye haliddisiṅgiverakaḷīrādayo, khandhakhādanīye uppalapaṇṇadaṇḍādayo, pupphakhādanīye campakapupphādayo, aṭṭhikhādanīye madhukaṭṭhieraṇḍasāsapādayo, piṭṭhakhādanīye adhotatālapiṭṭhādayo ca saṅgahitāti daṭṭhabbā.
97 97. 现在,为了从一切方面说明终生药,由于无法逐一列举,就把已说过的和未说过的合在一起,在其中安立特相,而说“根”等。其中,本来应该说“萨罗”,却因为词性颠倒而说成“萨拉”。因为尼犍度词典中说:“萨罗有力量、坚固、精华之义。”所谓“食义”,是指由食物所生的意义和作用;而这也就是所谓的“食的作用”。巴利
97. Idāni sabbaso yāvajīvikaṃ dassetuṃ asakkuṇeyyattā vuttāni ca avuttāni ca ekato sampiṇḍetvā tattha lakkhaṇaṃ ṭhapento ‘‘mūla’’ntiādimāha. Tattha ‘‘sāro’’ti vattabbe ‘‘sāra’’nti liṅgavipallāsenāha. ‘‘Sāro bale thiraṃse cā’’ti hi nighaṇḍu. Āhāraṭṭhanti āhārena jāto attho payojanaṃ āhārattho, sova āhāraṭṭho, taṃ āhārakiccanti vuttaṃ hoti.
98 98. 现在通过“一切”等语来说明四种药中可食与不可食等的区分。其中,“一切时药,其享用即受用”是复合词。“时”指午前时分。“一切”指病者与非病者。“有因缘时”的意思是:在这三种药中,夜分药是在有口渴等因缘时,七日药与终生药是在有疾病因缘时。超过时限就是非时;在非时中,夜分药若为食用而吞咽,七日药与终生药即使仅仅为了这个目的而接受,也犯恶作。巴利
98. Idāni catūsu kappiyākappiyādivibhāgaṃ dasseti ‘‘sabbā’’tiādinā. Tattha sabbe kālikā, tesaṃ sambhogo anubhavoti samāso. Kāleti pubbaṇhakāle. Sabbassāti gilānāgilānassa. Sati paccayeti tīsu yāmakālikaṃ pipāsādikāraṇe sati, sattāhakālikaṃ yāvajīvikañca gelaññakāraṇe satīti attho, kālato vigato vikālo, tasmiṃ, yāmakālikaṃ vikāle āhāratthāya ajjhoharaṇe, sattāhakālikaṃ pana yāvajīvikañca tadatthāya paṭiggahaṇamattepi dukkaṭaṃ.
99 “二者”是指时限药和夜分药。其中,时限药如果超过了自己的时限,就依非时食学处犯波逸提;夜分药如果超过了夜分,就依蓄藏学处犯波逸提。这两种情况都会造成内宿和蓄藏,这就是它们之间的关联。“内宿蓄藏”这个说法是以状态为重点的说明,意思就是内宿的状态和蓄藏的状态。巴利
99.Ubhoti yāvakālikaṃ yāmakālikañca. Tattha yāvakālikaṃ attano kālātikkantaṃ vikālabhojanabhikkhāpadena pācittiyaṃ janayati, yāmakālikaṃ yāmātikkantaṃ sannidhisikkhāpadena. Ete ubhopi antovutthañca sannidhiñca janayantīti sambandho. ‘‘Antovutthaṃ sannidhi’’nti bhāvappadhānoyaṃ niddeso, antovutthattaṃ sannidhittañcāti attho.
100 “已过时”是指已经超过了时限。“波逸提”的意思是:超过七天的(药),按照药品学处,就构成舍堕罪。如果两个人共有的东西由其中一人受持,还没有分配,那么超过七天时,两个人都没有犯,但不能拿来受用。“未载于圣典”是和“于圣典中未载的酥油等,超过七天”相连的。“酥”指人等的酥油。用“等”字还包括他们的生酥、椰子等油,以及用冷水调制的蜂蜜糖浆。巴利
100.Atināmiteti atikkāmite. Pācittīti sattāhātikkantaṃ bhesajjasikkhāpadena nissaggiyapācittiyāpatti ca hotīti attho. Sace dvinnaṃ santakaṃ ekena paṭiggahitaṃ avibhattaṃ hoti, sattāhātikkame dvinnampi anāpatti, paribhuñjituṃ pana na vaṭṭati. Pāḷināruḷheti pāḷiyaṃ anāruḷhe sappiādimhi satta ahāni atināmiteti sambandho. Sappīti manussādīnaṃ sappi. Ādi-saddena tesaṃyeva navanītaṃ, nāḷikerāditelaṃ, sītodakena kataṃ madhukapupphaphāṇitañca saṅgahitaṃ.
101 “舍已得”是指:已经舍掉、通过律法羯磨而舍弃,然后又照样重新得到,所以叫“舍已得”。“取彼”是剩下的部分。至于舍弃的具体做法,应当按后面将要讲的方式来了知。“涂”等词只是举例而已。用那些东西涂过的袈裟等物,则完全不能受用。但别人用身体去接触使用,是可以的。“对沙弥等作净施,在七日之内”——这里注疏中引了罪分圣典:“以‘我把这酥净施给你’等说法,称他们的名字,通过面前净施和非面前净施的方式说明其含义,那些促成此事的人,如果在未净施的情况下想成是已净施,就犯舍堕。”注疏先说了过失:“如果对已受具足戒的人作净施,那就只成了自己的东西,而且也没有舍掉受取。”然后说对未受具足戒的人作净施的目的,是为了没有自己的所有权、为了舍掉受取。对此我们说:罪分里根本没有“未净施”等这段圣典,因为它是从“对未决意之物想成已决意,舍堕;对未舍弃之物想成已舍弃,舍堕”等圣典引出来的,所以与之相应,在无犯部分里也只是从“决意、舍弃”等圣典来的。如果真有那段文,因为它是值得称赞的地方,就应该有注疏,但这里注疏中并没有。而且对未受具足戒的人作净施,怎么能舍掉受取呢?因为在舍弃学处等六种舍掉受取的原因中,净施并不包含在内,所以这里没有这个意思。巴利
101.Nissaṭṭhaladdhanti nissaṭṭhaṃ vinayakammavasena nissajjitañca taṃ laddhañca puna tathevāti nissaṭṭhaladdhaṃ. Taṃ gahetvāti seso. Nissajjanavidhānaṃ pana vakkhamānanayena veditabbaṃ. ‘‘Naṅga’’ntiādi upalakkhaṇamattaṃ. Tena makkhitāni kāsāvādīni ca pana aparibhogāniyeva . Aññassa pana kāyikaparibhogo vaṭṭati. Vikappentassa sattāhe sāmaṇerassāti ettha ṭīkāyaṃ ‘‘idaṃ sappiṃ tuyhaṃ vikappemī’’tiādinā tesaṃ tesaṃ nāmaṃ gahetvā sammukhāparammukhāvikappanavasena atthaṃ dassetvā taṃ sādhayantehi avikappite vikappitasaññī nissaggiyaṃ pācittiya’’nti āpattivāre pāḷi āhaṭā. ‘‘Sace upasampannassa vikappeti, attano eva santakaṃ hoti, paṭiggahaṇampi na vijahatī’’ti dosaṃ vatvā anupasampannassa vikappane attasantakattābhāvo, paṭiggahaṇavijahanañca payojanaṃ vuttaṃ. Tattha vadāma – āpattivāre ‘‘avikappite’’tiādipāḷiyeva natthi, ‘‘anadhiṭṭhite adhiṭṭhitasaññī nissaggiyaṃ pācittiyaṃ, avissajjite vissajjitasaññī nissaggiyaṃ pācittiya’’ntiādinā (pārā. 624) pāḷiyā āgatattā tadanurūpameva anāpattivāre ‘‘adhiṭṭheti, vissajjetī’’tiādināva pāḷi āgatā. Yadi bhaveyya, vaṇṇanīyaṭṭhānatāya aṭṭhakathāya bhavitabbaṃ, na cettha aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vijjati. Anupasampannassa vikappane ca kathaṃ paṭiggahaṇaṃ vijahati sikkhāpaccakkhānādīsu chasu paṭiggahaṇavijahanakāraṇesu vikappanassa anantogadhattā, tasmā nāyamettha atthoti.
我们在这里要说明的意思是:所谓“作净施”,这里的“净施”就是安排、分配,就像“心的思维”等说法那样,两处只是前缀不同而已。所以,在七天之内,沙弥或任何其他人作净施、作安排,生起舍弃想、舍弃思、舍弃意向,都没有犯戒。这就是这段话的意思。这是依据大苏摩长老的说法而说的。因为在“以彼心”等圣典语句中,为了显示意向,说过:“为什么这样说?是为了表明:在七天内送给别人,之后又拿回来受用,也没有犯戒。”但大巴杜摩长老则说:“这段话是为了表明,超过七天之后受用也没有犯戒。”在他们两种说法中,这一种更好。也就是说,在七天内,决意涂油等,或者送给别人,都没有犯戒,这是前后关联的意思。“等”字包括了涂药等。这里的意趣是:酥等、涂药等、蜜用来涂身,糖浆用来熏屋,这样决意的人没有犯戒。“别人”是指已受具足戒的人或未受具足戒的人。巴利
Mayamettha evamatthaṃ bhaṇāma – vikappentassāti ettha vikappanaṃ saṃvidahanaṃ ‘‘cittasaṅkappo’’tiādīsu viya, ubhayattha pana upasaggehi nānattamattaṃ, tasmā antosattāhe sāmaṇerassa yassa kassaci vikappentassa saṃvidahantassa pariccāgasaññaṃ pariccāgacetanaṃ pariccāgādhippāyaṃ uppādentassa anāpattīti attho. Idañca mahāsumattheravādamolubbha vuttaṃ. Vuttañhi ‘‘tena cittenā’’tiādīsu pāḷivacanesu adhippāyaṃ dassentena, ‘‘idaṃ kasmā vuttaṃ. Evañhi antosattāhe datvā pacchā paṭilabhitvā paribhuñjantassa anāpattidassanattha’’nti (pārā. aṭṭha. 2.625). Mahāpadumatthero panāha ‘‘sattāhātikkantassa pana paribhoge anāpattidassanatthamidaṃ vutta’’nti (pārā. aṭṭha. 2.625). Ayameva vādo tesu sundarataro. Sattāhe makkhanādiṃ adhiṭṭhato ca aññassa dadatopi ca anāpattīti sambandho. Ādi-saddena abbhañjanādiṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Ayametthādhippāyo – sappiādiṃ abbhañjanādiṃ madhuṃ arumakkhanaṃ, phāṇitaṃ gharadhūpanaṃ adhiṭṭhato anāpattīti. Aññassāti upasampannassa vā anupasampannassa vā.
102 时药等与自己混在一起时,会让它们取得自己的本性,这就是它们之间的关联。所谓自性,就是它自己的本性;在双数形式中说自性,就是那自性。因此,就是因为如此,所以说因此。如是所说,是指像作净施的人在七日内这样等所说的。这里的意思是:因为与自己混在一起的时药等,会让它们取得自己的本性,所以超过七日的七日药会生起波逸提罪,混在一起的、与自己混在一起的也会导致生起波逸提。因此,在不作净施等情况下,为了从差别上说明波逸提罪,才说了作净施的人等三句。不过在注疏里说:现在针对即将说的内容而说如是。这怎么能相应呢?因为即将说的内容不可能具有过去已说的性质。或者,如是所说是指在圣典和注疏中就是这样说的,这是它的意思。eva这个词是表示限定。巴利
102. Yāvakālikaādīni attanā saha saṃsaṭṭhāni sabbhāvaṃ gāhāpayantīti sambandho. Sabbhāvanti sassa attano bhāvo dvitte sabbhāvo, taṃ. Tasmāti yasmā evaṃ, tasmā. Evamudīritanti evaṃ ‘‘vikappentassa sattāhe’’tiādinā vuttaṃ. Ayamettha adhippāyo – yasmā attanā saṃsaṭṭhāni attano bhāvaṃ gāhāpayanti yāvakālikādīni, tasmā sattāhātikkāmitāni sattāhakālikāni pācittiyajanakāni saṃsaṭṭhāni attasaṃsaṭṭhānipi pācittiyajanakāni karontīti avikappanādimhi sati byatirekato pācittiyāpattiparidīpakaṃ ‘‘vikappentassā’’tiādikaṃ vākyattayaṃ vuttanti. Ṭīkāyaṃ pana ‘‘idāni vakkhamānaṃ sandhāya evanti vutta’’nti vuttaṃ. Taṃ vakkhamānassa atītaudīritattāyogato kathaṃ yujjatīti. Evamudīritanti vā pāḷiyaṃ aṭṭhakathāyañca evameva vuttanti attho. Eva-saddo avadhāraṇe.
103-5 现在,为了如实说明与自己相混的时药等如何取得自性,而说了“先前”等话。其中,“七日”是指有七天的那段时间,也就是七日药。“与”字在这里没有实际意义,应当理解为“七日与尽形寿”。“与其余时限混”是指与其余当天受取的时限药,也就是被称为时药、夜分药的那些相混。“波逸提”是指由蓄藏学处而犯的波逸提。“当日受取”是指在当天午前受取。“即于当日”也是指当天午前。“其余”是指七日药与尽形寿。“如是”应当理解为连接“只在夜分受用”。“其他”是指七日药之外的尽形寿。巴利
103-5. Idāni attasaṃsaṭṭhānaṃ yāvakālikādīnaṃ sabbhāvagāhāpanaṃ sarūpato dassetuṃ ‘‘pure’’tiādimāha. Tattha sattāhanti satta ahāni yassa taṃ sattāhaṃ, sattāhakālikaṃ. Ca-saddo aṭṭhānappayutto, so sattāhañca yāvajīvikañcāti yojetabbo. Sesakālikasammissanti sesehi tadahu paṭiggahitehi kālikehi yāvakālikayāmakālikasaṅkhātehi sammissaṃ. Pācittīti sannidhisikkhāpadena pācitti. Tadahu paṭiggahitanti tasmiṃyeva dine purebhattaṃ paṭiggahitaṃ. Tadahevāti tasmiṃyeva dine purebhattameva. Sesanti sattāhakālikaṃ yāvajīvikañca. Evanti yāme eva paribhuñjayeti vijānīyanti sambandho. Itaranti sattāhakālikato aññaṃ yāvajīvikaṃ.
第9品 受取分别的注释巴利
9. Paṭiggāhaniddesavaṇṇanā
106 106. “想布施”就是想要布施的人,其接近是哪怕只是稍微弯腰等之接近,这叫做依主释。手的范围就是“手范围”。不过按照习惯用法,两肘半的长度就叫“手范围”。如果比丘坐着,就从座位的后端算起;如果站着,就从脚跟算起;如果躺着,就从躺卧那一侧的外缘算起。但布施的人坐着或站着时伸出手,就要把伸出的手排除掉,以施者最近的那个身体部位的内侧边缘来界定,这样来理解。“堪举犁”是指中等力气的人能够举犁、适合的。“vatthusaddāpekkhaṃ napuṃsakattaṃ”是依词而取中性。“以三种方式布施”是指依身体、与身体相连之物、以及舍置物这三种方式,当施者布施时。其中,无论以任何身体部分,甚至哪怕只是脚趾布施,都叫做以身体布施;在以勺等物布施时,无论以任何与身体相连之物布施,则叫做以与身体相连之物布施;而从身体或与身体相连之物脱离后,置于手范围内,再以身体或与身体相连之物令其落入钵中,这叫做以舍置物的加行布施。“以两种方式受取”是指依身体和与身体相连之物这两种方式,对无论以何者所施之物的受取。如此,“受取具五支”是连接。所谓“具五支”,是具足五支,为多财释。巴利
106. Dātuṃ kāmetīti dātukāmo, tassa abhihāro īsakampi oṇamanādinābhiharaṇanti tappuriso, hatthassa pāso hatthapāso. Ruḷhīvasena tu aḍḍhateyyahattho hatthapāso nāma. So ca sace bhikkhu nisinno hoti, āsanassa pacchimantato paṭṭhāya, sace ṭhito, paṇhiantato paṭṭhāya, sace nipanno, yena passena nipanno, tassa pārimantato paṭṭhāya dāyakassa nisinnassa ṭhitassa vā ṭhapetvā pasāritahatthaṃ yaṃ āsannataraṃ aṅgaṃ, tassa orimantena paricchinditvā veditabbo. Eraṇakkhamanti thāmamajjhimena purisena eraṇassa ukkhipanassa khamaṃ yoggaṃ. Vatthusaddāpekkhaṃ napuṃsakattaṃ. Tidhā denteti kāyakāyappaṭibaddhanissaggiyānaṃ vasena tīhi pakārehi dāyake dadamāne. Tattha yena kenaci sarīrāvayavena antamaso pādaṅguliyāpi dīyamānaṃ kāyena dinnaṃ nāma hoti, kaṭacchuādīsu yena kenaci dīyamānaṃ kāyappaṭibaddhena, kāyato pana kāyappaṭibaddhato vā mocetvā hatthapāse ṭhitassa kāyena vā kāyappaṭibaddhena vā pātiyamānaṃ nissaggiyena payogena dinnaṃ nāma. Dvidhā gāhoti kāyakāyappaṭibaddhānaṃ vasena dvīhi pakārehi yehi kehici dīyamānassa gahaṇaṃ. Evaṃ paṭiggaho pañcaṅgoti yojanā. Pañcaṅgoti pañca aṅgāni yassāti bahubbīhi.
107 107. 现在,为了说明对既不能移动、又属于身体附属物的东西进行接受是不成立的,所以说了“不可移动的”等话。其中,“不可移动的”是指搬不动的木板、石头之类。“生于其处的”是指就长在那些树木等上面的紫矿花、莲花叶之类。这里要连起来理解:“枳椇等物的细叶”。因为那些东西撑不住。不过长在树枝上是可以的。用“等”字把“肢节”之类也包括进来。“或”字表示总括。“无法承受的重担”是指中等力气的人抬不起、撑不住的重担。对这一切的接受,都要和“不成立”连起来理解。巴利
107. Idāni aneraṇakkhame ca kismiñci kāyappaṭibaddhe ca paṭiggahaṇārohanaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘asaṃhāriye’’tiādimāha. Tattha asaṃhāriyeti ānetumasakkuṇeyye phalakapāsāṇādimhi. Tatthajāteti tesuyeva rukkhādīsu jāte kiṃsukapaduminipaṇṇādike. Ciñcaādīnaṃ sukhume paṇṇeti sambandho. Tāni hi sandhāretuṃ na sakkonti. Tesaṃ pana sākhāsu vaṭṭati. Ādi-saddena ‘‘aṅga’’ntiādikaṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Vā-saddo samuccaye. Asayhabhāreti thāmamajjhimapurisena sahituṃ sandhāretuṃ asakkuṇeyye bhāre. Sabbesaṃ paṭiggaho ‘‘na rūhatī’’ti iminā sambandho.
108 现在用“学”等来说明对受取的舍弃。其中,“以学、死、转相”是指通过舍学、死亡和转变性别。“无所期待的舍离”是指对此没有期待,那就是舍离,并由此而说。“以断”是指被贼等截断后取走。“以未受具足戒者施与”是指由未受具足戒者施与。“及”字应在各处加上。“取”就是受取。“舍弃”就是舍离。巴利
108. Idāni paṭiggahaṇavijahanaṃ dasseti ‘‘sikkhā’’tiādinā. Tattha sikkhāmaraṇaliṅgehīti sikkhāpaccakkhānena ca maraṇena ca liṅgaparivattanena ca. Anapekkhavisaggatoti natthi apekkho etassāti anapekkho, sova visaggo, tato ca. Acchedāti corādīhi acchinditvā gahaṇena. Anupasampannadānāti anupasampannassa dānena. Ca-saddo sabbattha ānetabbo. Gāhoti paṭiggahaṇaṃ. Upasammatīti vijahati.
109-10 现在为了说明未经接受而受用的过失,说了“未经接受”等话。其中,“一切”是指属于四种时段的全部。现在为了说明不必接受就可以受用的东西,说了“清净”等话。其中,应当这样连接:清净、不太浓的水、同样未从肢体断离的牙签、齿、眼、耳、身生的盐、鼻涕、粪,是允许的。其中,“清净”是指不混杂尘土和其他味道,所以清净。“不太浓”是指像耕地里的浓水那样,不会沾在嘴上或手上的那种。“未断”是指没有从肢体上断离而去。“齿、眼和耳”即齿眼耳,因为是身体肢体的部分,所以其粪便是依主释复合词。“盐”是指存在于身体中的。“鼻涕”即鼻涕物。断离了的则不应接受。巴利
109-10. Idāni appaṭiggahitaṃ paribhoge dosaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘appaṭiggahita’’ntiādimāha. Tattha sabbanti catukālikapariyāpannaṃ sakalampi. Idāni appaṭiggahetvā paribhuñjitabbaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘suddha’’ntiādimāha. Tattha suddhaṃ nātibahalaṃ udakañca tathā aṅgalaggaṃ avicchinnaṃ danta…pe… gūthakañca loṇa…pe… karīsakañca kappateti sambandho. Tattha suddhanti rajareṇūhi aññarasena ca asammissatāya parisuddhaṃ. Nātibahalanti yaṃ kasitaṭṭhāne bahalamudakaṃ viya mukhe vā hatthe vā na laggaṃ, taṃ. Avicchinnanti aṅgato vicchinditvā na gataṃ. Dantāni ca akkhīni ca kaṇṇañca dantakkhikaṇṇaṃ pāṇyaṅgattā, tassa gūthakanti tappuriso. Loṇaṃ sarīruṭṭhitaṃ. Siṅghāṇīti siṅghāṇikā. Vicchinnaṃ na paṭiggahetabbaṃ.
111 现在用“粪”等说法来显示时间界限。所谓“如是种类”,是指在像被蛇咬的那一刹那等这样一类的时间里。所谓“如是种类的时间属于此人”,这是多财释。“应服用”就是应当去服用,意思是应当受用。所谓“净人不在时”,应当知道:即便是难以沟通的、或者没有能力的净人,也都归在“不在”这一类里。不过,因为时间界限的缘故,如果没有灰烬,允许从树上砍下湿木来制作;如果没有泥土,允许挖地取土。巴利
111. Idāni ‘‘gūthā’’tiādinā kālodissaṃ dasseti. Tathāvidheti sappadaṭṭhakkhaṇādike tathāvidhe kāle. Tathā tādiso vidho kālo etassāti bahubbīhi. Seveyyāti sevanaṃ kareyya, paribhuñjeyyāti vuttaṃ hoti. Asante kappakāraketi ettha dubbacopi asamatthopi kappiyakārako asantapakkheyeva tiṭṭhatīti veditabbo. Kālodissattā pana chārikāya asati alladāruṃ rukkhato chinditvā kātuṃ, mattikāya asati bhūmiṃ khaṇitvāpi mattikaṃ gahetuṃ vaṭṭati.
112 “恶触”:粗暴地碰触、摸弄,就是恶触。如果比丘把没有受取过的、带有食物的容器从放着的地方移开去碰,碰它的盖子,把放在上面的尘垢等丢掉,或者抓住长在那里的果树树枝或藤蔓摇动,这就叫恶触。对此结罪:恶作。不过,为了靠一靠果树,或者在上面绑刺之类,是可以的。在树林里捡到掉落的芒果等,心想“我要给沙弥”,拿来布施,是可以的。“尘所覆”:被尘土覆盖。在钵等器物上,不管受取什么被尘土覆盖的东西,都有律制的恶作,这是这里的意思。如果托钵时尘土落进钵里,应该先受取再取食。即使对方说“受取后再给”,他们还是往里倒,也不该从手里放开,而应带到能受取的人跟前,让他受取。如果大风吹得各处尘土落下,没法取食,可以用“我要给未受具戒者”的清净心作意后取。而对方给的,或者以信任受取后受用,是可以的。巴利
112.Durūpaciṇṇeti duṭṭhuṃ upaciṇṇaṃ āmaṭṭhaṃ durūpaciṇṇaṃ. Sace bhikkhu appaṭiggahitaṃ sāmisaṃ bhājanaṃ ṭhitaṭṭhānato apanetvā āmasati, pidhānaṃ āmasati, upari ṭhitakacavarādiṃ chaḍḍeti, tatthajātakaphaliniyā sākhāya vā valliyā vā gahetvā vā cāleti, durūpaciṇṇaṃ nāma hoti. Tasmiṃ dukkaṭanti sambandho. Phalarukkhaṃ pana apassayituṃ vā tattha kaṇṭakaṃ vā bandhituṃ vaṭṭati. Araññe patitaambaphalādiṃ ‘‘sāmaṇerassa dassāmī’’ti āharitvā dātuṃ vaṭṭati. Rajokiṇṇeti rajasā okiṇṇe, tasmiṃ pattādike yaṃ kiñci paṭiggaṇhato vinayadukkaṭaṃ hotīti attho. Sace piṇḍāya carantassa patte rajaṃ patati, paṭiggahetvā bhikkhā gaṇhitabbā . ‘‘Paṭiggahetvā dethā’’ti vuttepi ākiranti, hatthato amocenteneva paṭiggāhāpakassa santikaṃ netvā paṭiggahetabbaṃ. Sace mahāvāto tato tato rajaṃ pāteti, na sakkā hoti bhikkhaṃ gahetuṃ, ‘‘anupasampannassa dassāmī’’ti suddhacittena ābhogaṃ katvā gaṇhituṃ vaṭṭati. Taṃ pana tena dinnaṃ vā vissāsena vā paṭiggahetvā paribhuñjituṃ vaṭṭati.
“然后”这个词,是在即将开始讲述的地方用的。“取受”的意思是:已经取了,就叫取;所取的东西,以及对它的接受,就在那上面。对于知道“这是没有接受过的状态”的人来说,他的意思是自己取了之后再拿。不过,为了父母而拿油等东西,并没有先接受;或者为了遮阴而拿树枝等,或者想以后再吃而先接受后食用,这些都是允许的。甘蔗等被劈开时,脏东西看不出来;研磨或捣碎根药等的人,磨石、小磨石、臼、杵都会损耗;牙缝里会夹着细微的食物,味道也尝不出来,这就成了不算数的东西。“落入内”的意思,是落进非净屋的屋顶里面。“自煮”的意思,是自己在哪里煮的。如果把斧头等加热后投进酪浆等里,光是这样也还是离不开自煮。除了前面两种情况下的再煮以外,比丘不允许煮任何食物。如果在热粥里放进罗勒叶等或者生姜,不允许搅动。拿到生米饭后,不允许盖上。“内煮”的意思,是在非净屋里面煮。应当连起来说:一切处都是恶作。巴利
Athāti vakkhamānārambhe. Uggahappaṭiggaheti uggahitthāti uggaho, uggahitaṃ, tassa paṭiggaho, tasmiṃ. Appaṭiggahitabhāvaṃ jānato attanā eva uggahetvā gahaṇeti adhippāyo. Mātāpitūnaṃ atthāya pana appaṭiggahetvā telādīni, chāyatthāya sākhādīni vā gahetvā pacchato bhuñjitukāmatāya paṭiggahetvā paribhuñjituṃ vaṭṭati. Ucchuādīsu phālitesu malaṃ na paññāyati, mūlabhesajjādīni pisantānaṃ vā koṭṭentānaṃ vā nisadanisadapotakaudukkhalamusalāni khīyanti, dantantare laggaṃ sukhumaāmisaṃ hoti, raso na paññāyati, abbohārikaṃ. Antovuttheti akappiyakuṭiyā chadanabbhantare vuttheti attho. Sayaṃpakketi attanā yattha katthaci pakke. Sace vāsiādiṃ tāpetvā takkādīsu pakkhipati, ettāvatāpi sāmapākato na muccati. Purimakālikadvaye punapākañhi ṭhapetvā yaṃ kiñci āmisaṃ bhikkhuno pacituṃ na vaṭṭati. Sacepissa uṇhayāguyā sulasipaṇṇādīni vā siṅgiveraṃ vā pakkhipanti, cāletuṃ na vaṭṭati. Uttaṇḍulaṃ bhattaṃ labhitvā pidahituṃ na vaṭṭati. Antopakketi akappiyakuṭiyā anto pakke. Sabbattha dukkaṭanti sambandho.
第10品 不净肉品释义巴利
10. Akappiyamaṃsaniddesavaṇṇanā
113-4 人和象、马……以及蛇的肉,还有指定给比丘的肉,以及没有经过查看的肉,在这些肉当中——要这样把句子连接起来理解它的意思。其中,那些以头颈摇摆着行走的,是熊类之中特别的熊。用“蛇”这个词,把所有长条形的众生都包括进去了。“指定给比丘的肉”:是指定给比丘而做的,那就是指定做的,这种肉就是指定给比丘的肉。在这里,通过“肉”这个词,按照标示的方式,或者通过“以及”这个词,应该知道也包含了鱼肉。在五种同法者中,任何指定做的肉对一切人都不允许,但那肉由于未见、未闻、无疑,三净则可用。“未经查看”:意思是未经审察、未经询问。因为害怕犯戒的比丘,即使是在观察色相时,也应当询问后接受和受用。在人肉中,是土喇咤亚罪——这样连接理解。这里“粗重”,在短音、重复音节时称为“土喇咤亚”。除了波罗夷、僧残之外,没有比这更重的罪了。在其余的中——在剩余的十一种中。巴利
113-4. Manussahatthiassānañca …pe… uragassa ca yaṃ maṃsañca, yaṃ uddissakatamaṃsañca, appaṭivekkhitaṃ yañca maṃsaṃ, tesu maṃsesūti evaṃ yojetvā attho veditabbo. Tattha sīsagīvātaraṅgena carantā acchavisesāva taracchā. Uragassāti iminā sabbāpi dīghajāti saṅgahitā. Uddissakatamaṃsanti bhikkhuṃ uddisitvā kataṃ uddissakataṃ, tañca taṃ maṃsañca. Ettha ca maṃsa-ggahaṇena macchānampi gahaṇaṃ veditabbaṃ upalakkhaṇavasena, ca-saddena vā. Pañcasupi sahadhammikesu yaṃ kiñci uddissakataṃ sabbesampi na kappati, tampi adiṭṭhaasutaaparisaṅkitatāya tikoṭiparisuddhaṃ vaṭṭati. Appaṭivekkhitanti anupaparikkhitaṃ, anāpucchitanti attho. Āpattibhīrukena hi rūpaṃ sallakkhentenāpi pucchitvā paṭiggahetabbaṃ paribhuñjitabbañca. Manussānaṃ maṃsesu thullaccayanti yojanā. Thūlo accayo etthāti rasse, dvitte ca thullaccayaṃ. Pārājikasaṅghādisesehi ṭhapetvā ito adhikaṃ vajjaṃ natthi. Sesesūti avasesesu ekādasasu.
115 115. 现在为了说明人等的骨等也是不可用的,就说了“骨也”等话。“也”这个字也要贯穿到“血”等词上。“这些”:指的是人等的十种骨等。不过在油脂当中,只有人的油脂一种是不允许的。在乳等物当中,并没有所谓不可用的东西。“只有特意为(比丘)而做的才是有心”——应当这样连接理解。“有心”:是指与知道“这是特意为比丘而做的”那个心一起生起,所以叫“有心”。因为是以明知而违犯对象的心,才成为“有心性”。在这里,有心性只属于罪过本身,并不属于肉;尽管如此,应当知道这里是拿肉作为首要来说罪过的。巴利
115. Idāni manussādīnaṃ aṭṭhiādīnipi akappiyānīti dassetuṃ ‘‘aṭṭhipī’’tiādimāha. Pi-saddo ‘‘lohita’’ntiādīsupi anuvattetabbo. Esanti manussādīnaṃ dasannaṃ. Vasāsu pana ekā manussavasā na vaṭṭati. Khīrādīsu akappiyaṃ nāma natthi. Uddissakataṃyeva sacittakanti yojanā. Sacittakanti uddissakatabhāvajānanacittena saha vattatīti sacittakaṃ. Vatthuvītikkamavijānanacittena hi sacittakattaṃ. Ettha ca sacittakattaṃ āpattiyā eva, na ca maṃsassa, tathāpi maṃsasīsena āpatti eva vuttāti viññātabbanti.
第11品 舍堕品释义巴利
11. Nissaggiyaniddesavaṇṇanā
116-7 用金钱换非金钱和金钱,用另一种东西换金钱,这就是它们的关联。其中,用金钱是指用被称为金钱的舍堕物。非金钱是指被称为非金钱的恶作和如法物。用另一种东西是指用非金钱。舍堕就是舍弃,这是对前期应当做的律仪羯磨的称呼。舍堕就是具有应舍弃的,那是什么?是波逸提。不过在收取金钱的根本上,以不受取金钱学处,成为舍堕波逸提。巴利
116-7. Rūpiyena arūpiyaṃ rūpiyañca itarena rūpiyañca parivatteyyāti sambandho. Tattha rūpiyenāti rūpiyasaṅkhātena nissaggiyavatthunā. Arūpiyanti arūpiyasaṅkhātaṃ dukkaṭavatthuṃ kappiyavatthuñca. Itarenāti arūpiyena. Nissaggīti nissajjanaṃ nissaggo, pubbabhāge kattabbassa vinayakammassetaṃ nāmaṃ. Nissaggo assa atthīti nissaggi, kiṃ taṃ? Pācittiyaṃ. Rūpiyassa mūlaggahaṇe pana rūpiyappaṭiggahaṇasikkhāpadena nissaggiyaṃ pācittiyaṃ.
现在为了说明金钱等,开始讲“在此”这一段。其中,kahāpaṇa……(中略)……māsaka,在这里就是金钱,应当这样连接。其中,所谓kahāpaṇa,就是金制的或银制的,或者现在普通的kahāpaṇa。sajjhu就是银。siṅgī是金的一种,不过这里一般就是指金。vohārūpagamāsaka,就是进入交易、买卖的,所以叫vohārūpaga,那就是这种māsaka。而这种钱币,不论是已经加工成的还是没加工成的,都说是铁、木等做成的。在这里就是金钱,意思是:在这个学处里,所说的金钱。衣服、珍珠等许可的东西,和恶作的东西,是另外一类,应当这样连接。其中,衣服和珍珠等,是复合词。等字应当分别连接,就是“衣服等、珍珠等”。其中,第一个等字,包括棉线、后熟作物等任何许可的东西;第二个等字,包括宝石、螺、石、珊瑚、红宝石、玛瑙、七种谷物、奴婢、田地、花园、果园等,这些是恶作的东西。衣服等许可的东西,和珍珠等恶作的东西,是另外的、别的非金钱,就是这个意思。巴利
Idāni rūpiyādiṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘idhā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Tattha kahā…pe… māsakaṃ idha rūpiyanti sambandho. Tattha kahāpaṇo nāma suvaṇṇamayo vā rajatamayo vā etarahi pakatikahāpaṇo vā. Sajjhūti rajataṃ. Siṅgīti suvaṇṇabhedo, tathāpi cettha sāmaññena suvaṇṇamadhippetaṃ. Vohārūpagamāsakanti vohāraṃ kayavikkayaṃ upagacchatīti vohārūpagaṃ, tañca taṃ māsakañca. Taṃ pana samuṭṭhāpitarūpañca asamuṭṭhāpitarūpañca lohadāruādimayaṃ vuccati. Idha rūpiyanti imasmiṃ sikkhāpade rūpiyaṃ nāmāti attho. Vatthamuttādi kappaṃ dukkaṭavatthuñca itaranti yojanā. Tattha vatthañca muttā ca ādi yassāti samāso. Ādi-saddo paccekaṃ yojetabbo ‘‘vatthādi muttādī’’ti. Tattha paṭhamena ādi-saddena kappāsasuttāparaṇṇādikaṃ yaṃ kiñci kappiyavatthuṃ, dutiyena maṇi saṅkho silā pavāḷaṃ lohitaṅko masāragallaṃ sattadhaññāni dāsidāsakhettavatthupupphārāmaphalārāmādayoti idaṃ dukkaṭavatthuṃ saṅgaṇhāti. Vatthādikappiyavatthuṃ, muttādidukkaṭavatthuñca itaraṃ aññaṃ arūpiyaṃ nāmāti attho.
118 到这一步,已经说明了金钱交易。现在为了说明允许物品的买卖,说出“此……”等话。其中,应当这样连接:在买卖完成时,说“拿这个给他,做这个,把这个拿来”,或者说“吃了这个给他,做这个,把这个拿来”,或者说“我给这个,你给这个,做这个,把这个拿来”,就构成舍堕。其中,“这个”指米等。“吃了”指吃了饭等。“给这个”指给这个衣服等。“做这个”指做这个染色、煮染等。“把这个拿来”指把这个染木等拿来。“我给这个”指我把这个衣服等给你。“完成”指做的时候。因此,交换允许物品的人,对不认识的人说“给这个”时是乞求,说“拿这个”时是信施物的失坏,说“用这个换那个”时是买卖——说了这三种罪过。不过和父母之间,应当只免除买卖本身。这种买卖,除了五种同法者以外,对其余在家和出家的人都不允许。但如果让人做新工程,应当按注疏的标准,只说波逸提。巴利
118. Ettāvatā rūpiyasaṃvohāraṃ dassetvā idāni kappiyabhaṇḍe kayavikkayaṃ dassetumāha ‘‘ima’’ntiādi. Tattha ‘‘imaṃ gahetvā imaṃ dehi, imaṃ kara, imaṃ ānayā’’ti vā ‘‘imaṃ bhutvā imaṃ dehi, imaṃ kara, imaṃ ānayā’’ti vā ‘‘imaṃ demi, imaṃ dehi, imaṃ kara, imaṃ ānayā’’ti vā kayavikkaye samāpanne nissaggīti yojanā. Tattha imanti taṇḍulādiṃ. Bhutvāti odanādiṃ bhuñjitvā. Imaṃ dehīti etaṃ vatthādikaṃ dehi. Imaṃ karāti etaṃ rajanapacanādiṃ karohi. Imaṃ ānayāti etaṃ rajanakaṭṭhādiṃ ānehi. Imaṃ demīti etaṃ vatthādikaṃ tava demi. Samāpanneti kate. Tasmā kappiyaṃ bhaṇḍaṃ parivattentena aññātakehi saddhiṃ ‘‘imaṃ dehī’’ti vadato viññatti, ‘‘imaṃ gaṇhāhī’’ti vadato saddhādeyyavinipātanaṃ, ‘‘iminā imaṃ dehī’’ti vadato kayavikkayanti vuttā tisso āpattiyo. Mātāpitūhi pana saddhiṃ kayavikkayamattaṃ mocentena parivattetabbaṃ. Ayañhi kayavikkayo ṭhapetvā pañcasahadhammike avasesehi gihipabbajitehi na vaṭṭati. Sace pana navakammāni kāreti, aṭṭhakathāpamāṇena pācittiyamattaṃ desetabbaṃ.
119-120 119-120. 现在,为了通过转让的方式说明犯戒的差别,开始说“自己的”等语。这里总的含义是:把属于僧团的东西转让给自己,是舍堕。转让给别的个人,是波逸提。转让给别的僧团或塔庙,是恶作。把属于别的个人或塔庙的东西转让给自己、或僧团、或别的个人、或别的塔庙,是恶作——应当这样连接理解。其中,“属于”是指以身或语表示倾向。“东西”是指应得的衣等物品。“别的”是指在别的个人或塔庙那里;不过对塔庙则是恶作。“别的之”是指塔庙等,乃至狗。“或别的”是指或在塔庙等那里。“僧团之”这一句,用乌鸦眼珠法,“把属于的……转让”在两处都适用。“已舍出者,以自己所有想而不给,是恶作”——应当这样连接。否则,就是以另一种方式,以盗心想而不给——这就是所说的意思。“其他”是指根据对象不同,另外还有波罗夷、土喇咤亚和恶作的意思。巴利
119-120. Idāni pariṇāmanavasena āpattibhedaṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘attano’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Tatthāyaṃ piṇḍattho – saṅghassa nataṃ lābhaṃ attano pariṇāmeyya, nissaggi. Aññato puggalassa pariṇāmeyya, pācitti. Aññassa saṅghassa vā cetiyassa vā pariṇāmeyya, dukkaṭaṃ. Aññassa puggalassa vā cetiyassa vā nataṃ lābhaṃ attano vā saṅghassa vā aññapuggalassa vā aññacetiyassa vā pariṇāmeyya, dukkaṭanti yojanā. Tattha natanti kāyena vā vacasā vā ninnaṃ kataṃ. Lābhanti labhitabbaṃ cīvarādi. Aññato aññasmiṃ puggale vā cetiye vā, cetiye pana dukkaṭaṃ. Aññassāti cetiyādino antamaso sunakhassa. Aññato vāti cetiyādimhi vā. Saṅghassāti pana idaṃ kākakkhigoḷakañāyena ‘‘nataṃ pariṇāmeyyā’’ti ubhayattha parivattati. Nissaṭṭhaṃ sakasaññāya na dadeyya vā, dukkaṭanti sambandho. Aññathā aññena pakārena, theyyasaññāya na dadeyya ceti vuttaṃ hoti. Itaranti vatthuvasena aññaṃ pārājikaṃ thullaccayaṃ dukkaṭañca hotīti attho.
波逸提说明的注释巴利
12. Pācittiyaniddesavaṇṇanā
121 “妄语……(中略)……‘夺取’”中的“夺取”是表示原因的地格,它和“已说波逸提”这句话相连。一切地方都是这样。“妄语”是与不变词组合的依主释复合词。意思是:在开口之前就已经知道,在说出口的那一刻也知道,这就是说妄语的相状。这里所说的“说”,是指把不实的当成真实的,或者把真实的当成不实的,通过身体或语言做出让对方知道的行为。如果有人以没有根据的指控,依次指责他人犯波罗夷、僧残或一般违犯,那么指责者依次犯僧残、波逸提、恶作。如果没有经过审查就仓促说话,或者心想“我要说别的”却说成了别的,而对其说(妄语)的那个人并没有听见,那就不犯。巴利
121.Musā…pe… haraṇeti nimittatthe bhummavacanaṃ, tassa ‘‘pācitti vuttā’’ti iminā sambandho. Evaṃ sabbattha. Musāvādeti nipātena saddhiṃ tappuriso. Pubbepi jānitvā vacanakkhaṇepi jānantassa musābhaṇananimittanti attho. Bhaṇanañca nāma idha abhūtassa vā bhūtataṃ, bhūtassa vā abhūtataṃ katvā kāyena vā vācāya vā viññāpanappayogo. Pārājikasaṅghādisesācāravipattiyo amūlikāya codentassa yathākkamaṃ saṅghādisesapācittiyadukkaṭāni. Anupadhāretvā sahasā bhaṇantassa, ‘‘aññaṃ bhaṇissāmī’’ti aññaṃ bhaṇantassa yassa bhaṇati, so na suṇāti, tassa ca anāpatti.
“omasati”的意思是:就像用不悦耳的话刺进别人耳朵里;或者说,用这种话去辱骂,就叫“omasa”,而这本身就是言语,所以说“在辱骂语中”。这里的长音只是按照偈颂的韵律拉长的。其他地方也都这样理解。所谓低劣和高贵,是指在种姓、名字、姓氏、年龄、职业、技艺、疾病、相貌、烦恼、罪过、辱骂这十类所包含的骂人话中,用真实的或不真实的话,比如“你是刹帝利”“你是旃陀罗”等等,通过身体或言语——而不是用间接暗示的方式——怀着想羞辱比丘的心说出辱骂的话,这就是这里的意思。如果用“这里有某些旃陀罗”这类话间接指责,或者用经典以外的说法,比如“你是贼”“你是变态”“你是杀母的人”等来指责比丘,或者用某种方式对未受具足戒者指责,或者在背后辱骂任何人,都犯恶作。但如果只是出于开玩笑的心而说,那么在任何情况下都只是恶说。巴利
Omasati amanāpatāya kaṇṇesu vijjhati viya etena, omasati vāti omaso, so cāyaṃ vādoca, tasmiṃ. Dīgho pana gāthābandhavasena. Evaṃ sabbattha. Hīnukkaṭṭhesu ca jātināmagottavayakammasippaābādhaliṅgakilesaāpattiakkosasaṅkhātesu dasasu bhūtena vā abhūtena vā ‘‘khattiyosi, caṇḍālosī’’tiādinā kāyena vā vācāya vā anaññāpadesena bhikkhuno khuṃsetukāmatāya akkosavacaneti attho. ‘‘Santi idhekacce caṇḍālā’’tiādinā aññāpadesena vā ‘‘corosi, vikārīsi, mātughātakosī’’tiādīhi pāḷimuttapadehi vā bhikkhussa, yathā vā tathā vā anupasampannaṃ, parammukhā pana sabbampi akkosantassa dukkaṭaṃ. Kevalaṃ davakamyatāya vadato pana sabbattha dubbhāsitaṃ.
“传两舌”是指:两舌的状态就是两舌。或者因为想让自己讨人喜欢,或者因为想让别人之间产生分裂,比丘用种姓等话轻蔑对方,听了这个比丘的话之后,再把这种两舌的话传给那个比丘,这就是传两舌。传给未受具足戒的人,犯恶作。“逐句”:一句一句地,就是“逐段地”,意思是按一段一段来。“法”是指三次结集所收录的三藏法,以及没有收录的国王教诫等法,和这些一起称为“逐句”,这是不变词与第三格组成的复合词。“逐句法”:意思是用一字等为一段,一段一段地和未受具足戒的人一起,按照所说的法来诵说。所谓逐句法诵说,其实是借“逐句法”这个词来指代。和未受具足戒的人一起受持诵读,或者在他面前受持诵读,或者和他一起诵已经背得很熟的经典,在停顿或出错的地方说“应该这样念”,即使和他一起念,也没有犯。巴利
Pesuññaharaṇeti pisuṇassa bhāvo pesuññaṃ. Attano piyakamyatāya vā parassa paresu bhedādhippāyena vā jātiādīhi omasantassa bhikkhuno vacanaṃ sutvā bhikkhussa tassa pesuññassa haraṇe. Anupasampannassa haraṇe dukkaṭaṃ. Padaṃ padaṃ padaso, vicchāyaṃ so, koṭṭhāsena koṭṭhāsenāti attho. Saṅgītittayāruḷho tipiṭakadhammo, anāruḷho ca rājovādādiko dhammo nāma, tena saha padasoti nipātassa tatiyātappuriso. Padasodhammeti ekakkharādinā koṭṭhāsena koṭṭhāsena anupasampannena saddhiṃ yathāvuttadhammabhaṇaneti attho. Padasodhammabhaṇanañhi padasodhamma-saddena upacārena vuttaṃ. Anupasampannena saddhiṃ ekato uddesaggahaṇe sajjhāyakaraṇe, taṃsantike uddesaggahaṇādike ca tena saddhiṃ ekato yebhuyyena paguṇaṃ ganthaṃ bhaṇantassa osārentassa khalitaṭṭhāne ‘‘evaṃ bhaṇāhī’’ti ekato bhaṇantassapi anāpatti.
所谓“住所”,最低限度哪怕是用布料等任何东西,只要没有碰到完全覆盖的遮盖物,即使只有一肘半高,只要是大部分覆盖、大部分围起来的住处,就叫作“屋”。至于住在那里的人,除了比丘以外,哪怕是一只构成波罗夷罪的畜生,哪怕是当天出生的女人,从近似意义上也用“屋”这个词来说。与屋在一起,就是“有屋者”,指的是比丘。不过要理解的是,仅仅从近似意义上说,和未受具戒者、和女人一起躺卧坐起,就叫作“有屋者状态”。僧团认可的、负责分配住所等事务的受具戒者,如果比丘们出于想让他丢脸的目的,用各种方式使(人)抱怨他、使(人)轻视他、使(人)用鄙视的眼光看他,或者使(人)把他想得很低劣,这些话就叫作“抱怨”。因为对他不满,到处宣扬他的坏话,这就叫“嫌恶”。巴利
Antamaso vatthādinā yena kenaci sabbacchannaṃ chadanaṃ anāhacca diyaḍḍhahatthubbedhenāpi sabbaparicchinnaṃ yebhuyyenachannaṃ yebhuyyenaparicchinnañca senāsanaṃ agāranti adhippetaṃ. Tatraṭṭho pana bhikkhuṃ ṭhapetvā antamaso pārājikavatthubhūto tiracchānagatopi antamaso tadahujātā itthīpi upacārato agāra-saddena vuccati. Saha agārenāti sāgāro, bhikkhu. Upacāreneva ca pana anupasampannena, mātugāmena ca saha seyyakappanaṃ sāgārabhāvo nāmāti gahetabbaṃ. Saṅghasammataṃ senāsanapaññāpakādibhedaṃ upasampannaṃ ayasakāmā hutvā bhikkhūhi yena ca ujjhāpenti avajānāpenti avaññāya olokāpenti, lāmakato vā cintāpenti, taṃ vacanaṃ ujjhāpanakaṃ. Yena khīyanti sabbattha tassa avaṇṇaṃ pakāsenti, taṃ khīyanaṃ.
122 “掌”指的是手掌。不过,用这个“掌”字来涵盖时,身体本身就是“掌”。“矛”是指与身体相关联的矛,是一种特别的兵器;但从标示的角度来说,一切与身体相关联的都可称为“矛”。“掌”和“矛”合在一起,就是“掌矛”。在这里,比丘因愤怒而举起掌矛,就是“掌矛”。如果没打中而出手打人,因为不是出于想打的心而给的,所以是恶作;如果是出于想打的心,就是波逸提。对未受具足戒者,是恶作。以求解脱为意图的,无犯。巴利
122.Talanti hatthatalamadhippetaṃ. Taggahaṇena pana kāyova talaṃ. Sattīti kāyappaṭibaddhā satti āvudhaviseso, upalakkhaṇattā pana sabbampi kāyappaṭibaddhaṃ satti. Talañca satti ca talasatti. Idha pana kopena bhikkhussa talasattiuggiraṇaṃ talasatti. Sace pana viraddho pahāraṃ deti, na paharitukāmatāya dinnattā dukkaṭaṃ, paharitukāmatāya pācittiyaṃ, anupasampanne dukkaṭaṃ, mokkhādhippāyassa anāpatti.
对已受具足戒的人,以已制定(的学处)来说他,或者对他所说的法不恭敬,这叫“不恭敬”。对未受具足戒的人,或者由已受具足戒的人、或者由其他人以未制定的(学处)来说他,对他所说的法不恭敬,就是恶作。巴利
Paññattena vadato upasampannassa vā tena vuccamānadhammassa vā anādarakaraṇaṃ anādaro. Anupasampannassa tena vuccamānassa vā upasampannena, parena vā apaññattena vā vuccamānassa anādare dukkaṭaṃ.
用“你戒腊未满”这类话让比丘生起追悔,是未受具足戒者的恶作。巴利
‘‘Ūnavasso tvaṃ maññe’’tiādinā bhikkhuno kukkuccassa uppādanaṃ anupasampannassa dukkaṭaṃ.
未先打招呼而入村:按通常的说法,本应先打招呼。在界内的近行处、能看见的近行处见到比丘后,若不说“我非时入村,先打招呼”,未打招呼便在非时入村,就犯戒。不过“不打招呼”中的长音,是连声所致。遇灾难时,无犯。巴利
Anāpucchā gāmappavesaneti pakativacanena pucchitumanurūpaṃ antoupacārasīmāya dassanūpacāre bhikkhuṃ disvā ‘‘vikāle gāmappavesanaṃ āpucchāmī’’ti anāpucchitvā vikāle gāmappavesane. Dīgho pana sandhivasena. Āpadāsu anāpatti.
“辗转食”是指:由于连声,“paro ca paro ca”成为“paramparā”,其中的“ma”只是连音而成。因此,“paramparā”是表示从生起之处以从格来说的语词,意思是从另一人又另一人那里得到而吃。这里的意思是:以五种食物之名被邀请的人,对于最初被邀请的每一种食物,不按次第,不用“我把我的饭食分给你”或“我舍弃”等话,不论当面或背后,也不管有没有舍弃,从另一处又另一处得到五种食物等而吃。在病时、施衣时、作衣时,无犯。巴利
Paramparabhojaneti paro ca paro ca paramparā ma-kāro sandhivasena, tasmā paramparā uppattavisayaapādānavacanaṃ, parato parato laddhā bhuñjaneti attho. Ayamettha adhippāyo – pañcahi bhojanehi nāmaṃ gahetvā nimantitassa yena yena paṭhamaṃ nimantito, tassa tassa bhojanato uppaṭipāṭiyā, ‘‘mayhaṃ bhattapaccāsaṃ tuyhaṃ dammī’’ti vā ‘‘vikappemī’’ti vā ādinā sammukhā vā parammukhā vā avikappetvā vā aññato aññato pañcabhojanādīni laddhā bhuñjamāneti. Gilānacīvaradānacīvarakārasamaye anāpatti.
123 123. “不收举卧具或住处而去”,这是连起来说的。“或”字表示集合。其中,所谓十种卧具,就是褥、枕、上敷、地敷、席、皮片、坐具、衬敷、草敷、叶敷。在这十种里,哪怕只是拿一种属于自己的雨季安居期间所用的卧具,在僧团所有、完全遮蔽、有守护的住处里,自己铺好或叫人铺好之后,按照铺好的样子放着,不让白蚁等咬坏,就以那样放着的方式不收举,然后越过有围墙的园林的围墙,或者没有围墙时的近行范围而去;同样,对于床、椅、枕、褥这些卧具,在雨季时在露地上自己铺好或叫人铺好之后,没有受具足戒的人不收举,就越过强壮中等男子扔石头所及的距离而去——这就是这里的意思。不过,在所说的情况之外,就是恶作。巴利
123. Seyyaṃ senāsanāni vā anuddharitvā gamaneti sambandho. Vā-saddo samuccaye. Tattha ‘‘bhisi cimilikā uttarattharaṇaṃ bhūmattharaṇaṃ taṭṭikā cammakkhaṇḍo nisīdanaṃ paccattharaṇaṃ tiṇasanthāro paṇṇasanthāro’’ti (pāci. 116) vuttāsu dasasu seyyāsu ekampi attano vassaggane gahetvā saṅghike sabbappaṭicchanne gutte senāsane santharitvā vā santharāpetvā vā yathā ṭhapitaṃ upacikādīhi na khajjati, tathā ṭhapanavasena anuddharitvā parikkhittassa ārāmassa parikkhepaṃ, aparikkhittassa upacāraṃ atikkamitvā gamane ca, tathā mañcapīṭhatisikocchasaṅkhātāni senāsanāni vassakāle ajjhokāse santharitvā vā santharāpetvā vā anupasampannena anuddharitvā thāmamajjhimassa purisassa leḍḍupātaṃ atikkamitvā gamane cāti attho. Yathāvuttato pana aññattha dukkaṭaṃ.
与女人一起长途旅行:意思是,彼此商量说“走吧,姊妹”“走吧,尊者”,即使没有约定“今天或明天”这类限定时间的约定,但指定了门口、指定了道路之后,与女人一起在长途路上行走。巴利
Itthiyā addhānagamaneti ‘‘gacchāma bhagini, gacchāma ayyā’’ti aññamaññaṃ saṃvidahitvā ‘‘ajja vā sve vā’’tiādinā niyamitakālavisaṅketaṃ akatvāpi dvāravisaṅketaṃ maggavisaṅketaṃ katvāpi itthiyā saddhiṃ addhānamaggagamaneti attho.
与一个一个的人各自单独坐:一个对一个,就是各自单独一人;意思是“和她单独坐”。没有与一个男人一起时一个女人的坐,也没有与一个女人一起时一个男人的坐;只有在与一个女人、与一个男人单独坐的情况下,已经坐下的比丘才犯波逸提。这就是要表达的意思。也有版本读作“与一个女人、一个男人单独坐”。巴利
Ekekāya nisīdaneti ekena ekāti ekekā, tassā nisajjāyāti attho. Ekena saha ekissā nisajjaṃ vinā ekāya saha ekassa nisajjaṃ nāma natthīti ekāya saha ekassa nisajjāyaṃ sati nisinnassa bhikkhuno pācittiyanti adhippāyo. ‘‘Ekāyekanisīdane’’ti vā pāṭho.
124 用呈现色法等恐怖形相,或者说恐怖的事情来恐吓已受具足戒的人。对未受具足戒的人,犯恶作。巴利
124. Rūpādīnaṃ upasaṃhārena, bhayānakakathākathanena vā upasampannassa bhiṃsāpane. Anupasampannassa dukkaṭaṃ.
打的时候,即使只是用莲花瓣打已受具足戒的人,也犯戒。对未受具足戒的人,即使是对畜生,也犯恶作。如果是为了挣脱,则无犯。巴利
Ākoṭane upasampannassa antamaso uppalapattenāpi pahāradāne. Anupasampannassa antamaso tiracchānagatassapi dukkaṭaṃ. Mokkhādhippāyassa anāpatti.
在僧团中间,被持律者追问时,对所问的事答成别的、用另一件事来搪塞这件事,这就是“异语”。同样被追问时,因为不想说而用沉默来烦扰对方,这就是“烦扰”。对异语者和烦扰者,用白二羯磨作了异语烦扰羯磨之后,如果再犯异语或烦扰,就犯波逸提;如果羯磨还没作,就犯恶作。看到某种违犯,被指出“贤友,这件事是你做的”,却不想说那件事,以沉默来烦扰僧团,这就是烦扰者。做了不如法的行为之后,在僧团中被以罪或事追问时,不想说那件事,反而用“谁犯的?在哪里犯的?”之类的方式,拿别的话来遮掩那句话,这个人就叫异语者。巴利
Saṅghamajjhe vinayadharena anuyuñjiyamānassa pucchitato aññassa vādo aññena aññaṃ paṭicaraṇaṃ aññavādo. Tatheva pucchiyamānassa akathetukāmatāya vihesanaṃ tuṇhībhāvo vihesā. Aññavādakassa vihesakassa ca ñattidutiyakammena aññavādakavihesakakamme kate puna aññavāde vihesāya pācittiyaṃ. Anāropite pana kamme dukkaṭaṃ. Kiñci vītikkamaṃ disvā ‘‘āvuso, idaṃ nāma tayā kata’’nti vutte taṃ na kathetukāmo tuṇhībhūto saṅghaṃ vihesetīti vihesako. Anācāraṃ ācaritvā saṅghamajjhe āpattiyā, vatthunā vā anuyuñjiyamāne taṃ akathetukāmo ‘‘ko āpanno, kismiṃ āpanno’’tiādinā nayena aññehi vacanehi taṃ vacanaṃ paṭicchādento yo aññaṃ vadati, ayaṃ aññavādako nāma.
“粗重”指的是波罗夷和僧残,但在这里只指僧残。揭露和掩盖合起来叫“揭露掩盖”,即粗重罪的揭露掩盖,这是一个依主释复合词。对于屡屡犯戒的比丘,为了他将来能够防护,不论是否划定罪的界限和家的界限,都应当三次请求听许之后再行事。除了获得比丘认可的情况之外,对未受具足戒的人,以“这个人泄露不净而犯了僧残”等方式,把事实和罪结合起来,揭露和告知他的粗重罪;以及用任何方法知道他的罪后加以掩盖;还有对非粗重罪的告知和掩盖——对未受具足戒的人,依照前面第五学处,其余涉及粗重罪的也犯恶作。巴利
Duṭṭhullaṃ nāma pārājikasaṅghādisesā, idha pana saṅghādisesova. Pakāso ca chādo ca pakāsachādo, duṭṭhullassa pakāsachādoti tappuriso. Abhiṇhāpattikassa bhikkhuno āyatiṃ saṃvaratthāya āpattipariyantaṃ kulapariyantañca katvā vā akatvā vā tikkhattuṃ apaloketvā kātabbaṃ. Bhikkhusammutiṃ ṭhapetvā anupasampannassa ‘‘ayaṃ asuciṃ mocetvā saṅghādisesaṃ āpanno’’tiādinā nayena vatthunā saddhiṃ āpattiṃ ghaṭetvā tassa duṭṭhullassa pakāsane ārocane ca, tasseva yena kenaci upāyena ñatvā chādane ca, aduṭṭhullārocane chādane ca, anupasampannassa pana purimapañcamasikkhāpade itarā duṭṭhullepi dukkaṭaṃ.
关于“戏水”这个词,这里应当理解为“戏”和“水”两个词的拆分解释。无论用身体的哪个部位,只要带着嬉笑玩耍的意图去触碰腋下等部位,就是“戏”;因为以嬉笑为特征的触碰就是戏。对未受具足戒的人这样做,犯恶作。在水中戏玩,就是带着嬉笑玩耍的意图,在脚踝以上的水里,以浮出水面、潜入水中的方式玩耍。这里所说的“玩耍”就是“戏”。坐船玩耍时,用手或木棍等击打水面,甚至只是以投掷东西来玩耍,或者玩弄钵里的酸粥等,都犯恶作。如果没有嬉笑玩耍的意图,就无犯。巴利
Hāsodaketi ettha hāse udaketi padavibhāgo veditabbo. Yena kenaci sarīrāvayavena hasādhippāyassa upakacchakādīsu hāse phusane. Hāsanimittañhi phusanaṃ hāso. Anupasampanne dukkaṭaṃ. Udake hāseti uparigopphake udake hasādhippāyassa ummujjananimujjanena kīḷāya. Kīḷā hi idha hāsoti vutto. Nāvāya kīḷato, hatthādinā kaṭṭhādinā vā udakaṃ hanato antamaso bhājanagatakañjikādīnipi khipanakīḷāya kīḷato dukkaṭaṃ. Ahasādhippāyassa anāpatti.
把比丘从僧团的住处赶出去,或者叫别人把他赶出去,这叫“从住处驱出”。在这里,如果只做一次动作,就犯一条罪;如果通过多个方式反复做,就按经过的“门”来累计犯戒的数量。把比丘从属于个人的住处赶出去、把他的资具赶出去,或者把未受具足戒的人或其资具赶出去,犯恶作。把行为不正的弟子或共住者赶出去,或者把跟自己关系亲近的人从住处赶出去,不犯。但把制造争吵的人从整座僧园里赶出去,也不犯。巴利
Nicchubhane vihārāti saṅghikavihārato bhikkhuno nikkaḍḍhananikkaḍḍhāpane. Ettha ca ekappayoge ekā, nānāpayoge dvāragaṇanāya āpattiyo. Puggalikanikkaḍḍhane, tassa parikkhāranikkaḍḍhane, anupasampannassa pana tassa parikkhārassa vā nikkaḍḍhane dukkaṭaṃ. Na sammāvattantānaṃ antevāsikasaddhivihārikānaṃ vā nikkaḍḍhane, attano vissāsikassa vihārā nikkaḍḍhane, bhaṇḍanakārakassa pana sakalasaṅghārāmato nikkaḍḍhane anāpatti.
明知床或椅子是僧团指定给年长比丘或病比丘的,却在那位比丘进出时,侵入并进入他的活动范围,在僧团精舍里怀着“谁觉得挤,谁就会离开”的意图,用坐或躺的方式占卧。若是在个人住处这样做,犯恶作。巴利
Anupakhajja sayaneti ‘‘vuḍḍho, gilāno, saṅghena dinno’’ti jānitvā mañcapīṭhānaṃ vā tassa bhikkhuno pavisantassa vā nikkhamantassa vā upacāraṃ anupakhajja anupavisitvā saṅghike vihāre ‘‘yassa sambādho bhavissati, so pakkamissatī’’ti adhippāyena nisīdananisajjanavasena sayane. Puggalike dukkaṭaṃ.
这里先标出“波逸提”这个名目,再举出一些公认的例子来说明。那些没有单独列出的同类情况,则可以用这个总说的表述收摄进去,应当这样理解。怎么理解呢?比如:亲手把任何财物布施给裸形外道等其他外道;为了自己而乞求酥、生酥、油、蜜、石蜜、鱼、肉、乳、酪这些上妙食物然后吃掉;进入与贪欲缠缚的男子或女子相应的家庭后,安坐或设座;受了五种食物中某一种的邀请后,不管已经吃了还是还没吃,都不先告诉在场的比丘,就在食前或食后进入其他家庭——除非是在布施衣物的时节或生病时;除了某一天以外,在其他日子没有生病却吃住处施食;限定夜晚的时段或药物的时段之后,已经受过劝请却又超出限制再乞求——除非是再次劝请,除非是常时劝请;除了有那种因缘以外,为了看军队而从村落出去;即使有因缘而去,在军中停留超过三夜;停留期间,为了看战场、兵力集结处、军营布置和军阵而前往;饮用用面粉等酿成的谷酒,以及用花等酿成的果酒;不是为了点灯、烧叶、煮食等事,而是出于想取暖,没有生病却点火或让人点火;没有取应量点净就受用新衣;把自己净施出去的衣,在没有归还的情况下受用;把属于比丘的钵等物,哪怕只是出于开玩笑的想法,也藏起来或让人藏起来;故意杀害畜生;对已经如法灭除的诤事,故意再提起,想让它重新作羯磨;明知地和盗贼团伙约定后一起上路;比丘们依学处对他说时,他不加审察就说“我不于此处学”;诽谤学处;没有“听了之后我就停止”的意图,却站在争论者附近偷听;对如法的羯磨给了欲之后,后来又生起呵责;僧团正在裁决时,不给欲就离开;僧团和合地给了衣之后,后来又生起呵责;除了在寺院内或住处内,取宝物或等同宝物之物,或让人取——以上都犯波逸提。巴利
Ettha ca pācittīti uddisitvā kānici pasiddhāni dassitāni. Avuttāni pana tādisāni imināva sāmaññavacanena saṅgahetvā veditabbāni. Kathaṃ? Acelakādiaññatitthiyānaṃ yassa kassaci āmisassa sahatthā dāne ca, sappinavanītatelamadhuphāṇitamacchamaṃsakhīradadhisaṅkhātānaṃ paṇītabhojanānaṃ attano atthāya viññāpetvā bhuñjane, rāgapariyuṭṭhitaitthipurisassa yogge kule anupavisitvā nisajjanakappane, pañcannaṃ bhojanānaṃ aññatarena nimantito tasmiṃ bhutte vā abhutte vā santaṃ bhikkhuṃ anāpucchitvā purebhattaṃ pacchābhattaṃ vā yasmiṃ kule nimantito, tato gilānacīvaradānakārasamayaṃ ṭhapetvā aññasmiṃ aññakulappavesane, ṭhapetvā ekadivasaṃ aññasmiṃ dine āvasathapiṇḍassa agilānena hutvā bhuñjane, rattiparicchedaṃ vā bhesajjaparicchedaṃ vā katvā pavāritato uttari aññatra puna pavāraṇāya aññatra niccappavāraṇāya viññāpane, aññatra tathārūpapaccayā gāmato nikkhantasenādassanāya gamane, paccayenapi gantvā tirattato uttari senāya vāse, tassa ca vasantassa yuddhaṭṭhānabalagaṇaṭṭhānasenānivesaanīkadassanatthaṃ gamane, piṭṭhādīhi katamajjasaṅkhātasurāya, pupphādīhi kataāsavasaṅkhātamerayassa ca pāne, padīpujjalapattapacanādikāraṇaṃ vinā visibbitukāmatāya agilānassa aggino jālanajālāpane, kappabinduṃ anādāya navacīvaraparibhoge, sāmaṃ cīvaraṃ vikappetvā apaccuddhāya paribhoge, bhikkhusantakapattādino antamaso hasādhippāyenapi apanidhāne apanidhāpane, sañcicca tiracchānagatassa jīvitavoropane, sañcicca yathādhammaṃ nihatādhikaraṇassa punakammāya ukkoṭane, sañcicca theyyasatthena saddhiṃ saṃvidhāya ekaddhānagamane, bhikkhūhi sikkhāpadehi vuccamānassa aññaṃ avicāretvā ‘‘na tattha sikkhissāmī’’ti bhaṇane, sikkhāpadavivaṇṇane, imesaṃ ‘‘sutvā oramissāmī’’ti adhippāyaṃ vinā vivādāpannānaṃ upassutiṭṭhāne, dhammikānaṃ kammānaṃ chandaṃ datvā pacchā khīyanadhammāpajjane, saṅghe vinicchaye vattamāne chandaṃ adatvā pakkamane, samaggena saṅghena cīvaraṃ datvā pacchā khīyanadhammāpajjane, aññatra ajjhārāmā ajjhāvasathā vā ratanassa vā ratanasammatassa vā uggaṇhanauggahāpane pācittiyanti.
13. 沙门行仪解说的注释巴利
13. Samaṇakappaniddesavaṇṇanā
125 “沙门净”是指沙门的称呼。“有”是“存在”或“曾经存在”的意思,这个词尾适用于现在时或过去时。那些根已扎稳而正在生长的,以及已经长大变得巨大的树木、藤蔓等,称为“生物”的聚落;或者,诸生物本身就是聚落、集合,叫做“生物聚”。对它动手,就是砍伐、劈开等,即是在这生物聚上。这里的处格是“以……为因”的意思,也就是说:以此因缘而犯波逸提。“已作净”与“沙门净”和“成为”相关联,即“已作净成为沙门净”。其中,“已作净”是“对它已作净”的多财释。以什么作净?所以说“以指甲”等。巴利
125.Samaṇakappāti samaṇavohārā. Bhavanti, ahesunti vā bhūtā, vattamāne, bhūte vā tappaccayo. Viruḷhamūlādibhāvaṃ āpajjitvā vaḍḍhamānakānaṃ, vaḍḍhitvā mahantabhāvaṃ pattānañca rukkhalatādisaṅkhātānaṃ bhūtānaṃ gāmo, bhūtā eva vā gāmo samūho bhūtagāmo. Tassa samārambho chedanaphālanādi, tasmiṃ. Nimittatthe cetaṃ bhummaṃ, taṃhetu pācittiyaṃ hotīti attho. Katakappiyaṃ samaṇakappiyaṃ bhaveti sambandho. Tattha kataṃ kappiyaṃ yassāti bahubbīhi. Kenāti āha ‘‘nakhenā’’tiādi.
126 现在,为了说明对什么事物动手,要把那个生物聚加以分别,所以开始说“彼根”等。“彼”就是指生物聚。令存在、令生起,这是使役词尾,意思是“被产生、被生起”。或者,“产生”就是生起,那本身就是“生起”;“令生起”是从名词词根来的主动词尾,意思是“被产生、已生起”。根、茎、种、芽、节,就是“根……节”。“节”就是关节。它们本身就是种子,由它们而被产生、被生起;或者,以它们为界限、以它们为因,而被产生、已生起——按照这两种解释,应当依次理解两种复合词。其中,根种就是姜黄、生姜等。巴利
126. Idāni yassa samārambho, taṃ bhūtagāmaṃ vibhajitvā dassetuṃ ‘‘sa mūlā’’tiādi āraddhaṃ. Soti bhūtagāmo. Bhavituṃ uppajjituṃ payojetīti kāritantā tappaccayo, pabhāvito uppāditoti attho. Atha vā pabhavanaṃ pabhavo, uppatti, sova pabhavo, pabhāvaṃ karotīti nāmadhātuto kattari tappaccayo, pabhāvito uppannoti attho. Mūlañca khandho ca bījañca aggañca phaḷu ca mūla…pe… phaḷūni. Phaḷu nāma pabbaṃ. Tāniyeva bījāni, tehi pabhāvito uppādito, atha vā tehi avadhibhūtehi, kāraṇabhūtehi vā pabhāvito uppannoti kamena vikappadvaye samāsadvayaṃ veditabbaṃ. Tattha mūlabījaṃ nāma haliddisiṅgiverādi.
茎种,是指菩提树、榕树等。种子种,是指早稻、晚稻等。芽种,是指香根草等。节种,是指甘蔗、芦苇等。其中,根种等五种属于种子类。由这些种子长出来的树、藤等,属于生物类。巴利
Khandhabījaṃ nāma assatthanigrodhādi. Bījabījaṃ nāma pubbaṇṇāparaṇṇādi. Aggabījaṃ nāma hiriverādi. Phaḷubījaṃ nāma ucchunaḷādi. Tattha mūlabījādīni pañca bījagāmo. Tannibbatto rukkhalatādi bhūtagāmo.
现在,针对种子聚的动手破坏,通过“已犯”这个词来说明:犯恶作罪。连接关系是:把种子从生物聚中分离出来,对动手破坏,犯恶作罪。“从生物聚分离出来”是依主释复合词。“种子”是指已经种在地里或还没种在地里的,以及已经长出一拃长的叶子、叶轮的根种等。“对动手”这里,在与kitaka接尾词结合、业格未说出时,属格生起,以可选性在两处都用宾格。“动手”就是着手破坏。因此,用“知道这朵花或这个果实,把它作净”等作净语,把从生物聚中分离出来的种子类,为了让它脱离种子聚,应当再次让人作净,然后才能受用。佛陀说:“诸比丘,我允许用五种沙门净来受用果实:火所净、刀所净、爪所净、无种,以及已出种为第五。”在这所说的五种当中,这里显示了爪所净等三种。巴利
Idāni tesu bījagāmasamārambhe dukkaṭaṃ dasseti aparaddhena. Bhūtagāmaviyojitaṃ bījaṃ ārambhe dukkaṭanti sambandho. Bhūtagāmato viyojitanti tappuriso. Bījanti bhūmiyaṃ ropitamaropitampi niggatavidatthimattapattavaṭṭipi mūlabījāni. ‘‘Ārambhe’’ti kitakapaccayassa yoge avutte kammani chaṭṭhuppattiyaṃ vikappena ubhayattha dutiyā. Ārambheti samārambhe. Tasmā ‘‘imaṃ pupphaṃ phalaṃ vā jāna, imaṃ kappiyaṃ karohī’’tiādinā kappiyavacanena bhūtagāmato viyojitaṃ bījajātaṃ bījagāmaparimocanatthaṃ puna kappiyaṃ kārāpetvā paribhuñjibhabbaṃ. ‘‘Anujānāmi, bhikkhave, pañcahi samaṇakappehi phalaṃ paribhuñjituṃ aggiparijitaṃ satthaparijitaṃ nakhaparijitaṃ abījaṃ nibbattabījaññeva pañcama’’nti (cūḷava. 250) vuttesu pañcasu nakhaparijitādīni tīṇi dassitāni.
127 现在,为了说明剩下的两种,说了“已出种”等前半段。其中,“已出种”就是“已生出”:由前缀ni和词根vatu(存在、转起)构成,这个后缀表示“已生出”的意思;种子已经生出,就是已出种,指的是芒果、波罗蜜等,要把种子生出、分离之后才能食用。“无种”指的是嫩芒果果实等。现在,为了说明种子聚和生物聚中作净方法的差别等,说了“锅”等。其中,“以锅束缚的种子”是就外在含义来说的。巴利
127. Idāni avasiṭṭhāni dve dassetuṃ ‘‘nibbattabīja’’ntiādikaṃ paṭhamaddhaṃ āha. Tattha nibbattabījanti nibbattaniyanti nibbattaṃ, nipubba vatu vattanetimasmā tappaccayo, nibbattaṃ bījaṃ yassa taṃ nibbattabījaṃ, bījaṃ nibbattetvā visuṃ katvā paribhuñjitabbaṃ ambapanasādi. Nobījaṃ nāma taruṇambaphalādi. Idāni bījagāmabhūtagāmesu kappiyakaraṇappakārādivisesaṃ dassento ‘‘kaṭāhā’’tiādimāha. Tattha kaṭāhena baddhaṃ bījaṃ yesanti bāhirattho.
128 128. 应当这样连接理解:在容器里,或者在地上,对于连结为一的种子,以及在一种作净的情况下。所谓“在种子们中”,是指在种子聚和生物聚中。因为在这里,生物聚也依照惯用语而被称为“种子”。巴利
128. Bhājane bhūmiyampi vā ekābaddhesu bījesu ekasmiñca kappiye kateti yojanā. Bījesūti bījagāmabhūtagāmesu . Bhūtagāmopi hi idha ‘‘bīja’’nti ruḷhīvasena vuccati.
129 “已放置”就是指已经放好。“应当再作净”的意思是:因为已经长出根和叶,所以成了生物聚;为了让种子聚从生物聚中脱离出来,应当再作净。因此说“那时它就是生物聚”。“hi”这个词表示原因。“那时”是指根和叶长出来的时候。如果只长出根,或者上面长出了芽,就允许从下面切断。可是,如果只长出根或只长出叶,即使长出像宝石那么大的枝条,也仍然属于种子聚所摄。巴利
129.Nikkhitteti ṭhapite. Kappiyaṃ puna kareyyāti jātamūlapaṇṇabhāvato bhūtagāmattā bhūtagāmato parimocitaṃ bījagāmaparimocanatthaṃ puna kappiyaṃ kāreyyāti attho. Tenāha ‘‘bhūtagāmo hi so tadā’’ti. Hi-saddo hetumhi. Tadāti mūle ca paṇṇe ca jātakāle sace mūlamattaṃ sañjāyati, uparibhāge sace aṅkuro jāyati, heṭṭhābhāge chindituṃ vaṭṭati. Mūlamattesu vā pana paṇṇamattesu vā niggatesu sacepi ratanappamāṇāpi sākhā nikkhamanti, bījagāmasaṅgahitā honti.
130 130. “水中生出的藻类”和“塔等处所生的藻类”也是生物聚——应当这样连接。用“等”这个字,是把墙壁等也包括进来。如果长不出两三片叶子,就归入芽种所摄。干燥的则应当扫除。“根和叶已经长出,种子也属于生物聚”——应当这样连接。用“叶”这个字,是为了排除仅仅刚发芽的状态。巴利
130. Udakasambhavo sevālo ca cetiyādīsu sevālo ca bhūtagāmovāti sambandho. Ādi-saddena pākārādiggahaṇaṃ. Yadi dve tīṇi paṇṇāni na jāyanti, aggabījasaṅgahaṃ gacchati. Sukkho pana sammajjitabbo. Mūlapaṇṇe viniggate bījopi bhūtagāmovāti sambandho. Paṇṇeti iminā aṅkuramattaṃ paṭikkhipati.
131 131. “在瓶等物的背面,藻类、蛇伞菌和霉菌,也都是恶作的事例。”应当这样连接。用“背面”这个词,表明里面不算数。“已开”指已经开放的蛇伞菌。“不可用”的意思是:不适合当作犯戒来论处。巴利
131. Ghaṭādipiṭṭhe sevālo ca ahichattakamakuḷañca dukkaṭasseva vatthūnīti sambandho. Piṭṭheti iminā anto abbohārikoti dasseti. Phullanti phullitaṃ ahichattakaṃ. Abyavahārikanti āpattivohārayoggaṃ na hotīti attho.
132 132. 在湿树上破坏树胶、树脂、菌类而拿取,或者在树上刻断文字,也犯波逸提——应当这样连接。其中“在彼处”就是指在湿树上。有些写本里能看到“vikopaya”这个读法,那不是正确的读法,因为它是第三人称的词尾,没有道理。应当采用“vikopiyā”这个读法。用“破坏后”这个词,是要表明:没有破坏而拿取,就不犯戒。巴利
132. Allarukkhe lākhāniyyāsachattāni vikopiya gaṇhato tattha akkharaṃ chindato vāpi pācittīti sambandho. Tatthāti allarukkhe. ‘‘Vikopaya’’nti potthakesu pāṭho dissati, so apāṭho paṭhamantatāya kāraṇābhāvato. ‘‘Vikopiyā’’ti pana pāṭho gahetabbo. Vikopiyāti iminā avikopetvā gahaṇe anāpattīti dīpeti.
133 所谓“木猴”之类,就是钉入木楔,做成木制机关,然后在上面挂上荆棘,这叫作“木猴”。用“等”字,是把绑荆棘之类的事也包括进去。应当这样理解:不允许为了割草等而做,也不允许打结。“割”就是割断的行为。巴利
133.Dārumakkaṭakādināti āṇiṃ koṭṭetvā dāruyantaṃ katvā tattha kaṇṭakaṃ olambenti, etaṃ dārumakkaṭakaṃ nāma. Ādi-saddena kaṇṭakabandhanādīnaṃ gahaṇaṃ. Tiṇādiṃ chindituṃ, gaṇṭhikaṃ kātuñca na kappatīti yojanā. Chinditunti chindanaṃ.
134 “或者植物”,即植物聚;“或者种子”,即种子聚。在“或者砍”等语句中,到处都要接上“或者”这个词。“或者煮”,即“或者去做煮的行为”。也有写成“paṭa”的版本,意思是使它生起。不过,不说“砍这棵树”这样指定对象,而说“砍树”这样不加指定,也是可以的。巴利
134.Bhūtagāmaṃ vāti bhūtagāmaṃ vā. Bījaṃ vāti bījagāmaṃ vā. ‘‘Chinda vā’’tiādinā sabbattha vā-saddo yojetabbo. Paca vāti pacanaṃ karohīti vā. ‘‘Paṭa’’ iti vā pāṭho, tassa uppādehīti attho. ‘‘Imaṃ rukkhaṃ chindāhī’’tiādinā pana avatvā ‘‘rukkhaṃ chindā’’tiādinā aniyametvā vattuṃ vaṭṭati.
135 “此”就是指这棵树等。在“清理此”这里,要把“如此”这个词加进去,然后说明它的意思。巴利
135.Imanti etaṃ rukkhādiṃ. Imaṃ sodhehīti ettha iti-saddaṃ katvā attho vattabboti.
第14章 地的解说注释巴利
14. Bhūminiddesavaṇṇanā
136 136. 对于在这些地方住过和煮过都获允许的,这些就是允许之地:僧悦地、僧悦屋……中略……居士和居士屋——应当这样把“这四种存在”连接起来理解其含义。其中,按照《药篇》(大品295)所说的白二羯磨语,或者以求听羯磨的方式告知后,如法完成告知,这就是“僧悦”;把柱子或墙基竖立起来、向上安置,并以“我们做净屋”这句话告知,这句话说完就是“告知终了”。因此说:“立柱与语终同时即为允许”(大品注295)。坐下、进入、安住就是“坐”,像牛的坐一样,所以叫“牛坐”。除了比丘以外,其余所有同法者以及一切天和人,在这里以“居士”作为通称。而在这里,与居士相关的屋,以长音称为“居士”。巴利
136. Yāsu vutthaṃ pakkañca kappati, tā kappiyā bhūmiyo sammuti ca sammutikuṭi ca…pe… gahapati ca gahapatikuṭi cāti imā catasso hontīti yojetvā attho veditabbo. Tattha bhesajjakkhandhake (mahāva. 295) vuttāya uttidutiyakammavācāya, apalokanakammavasena vā sāvetvā sammā uttisampannaṃ karīyatīti sammuti, thambhānaṃ bhittipādānaṃ vā uggamanaṃ uddhaṃ katvā ṭhapanaṃ, ‘‘kappiyakuṭiṃ karomā’’ti vācāya sāvanañca antaṃ yassā sā ussāvanantā. Tathā ca vuttaṃ ‘‘thambhappatiṭṭhānañca vacanapariyosānañca samakālaṃ vaṭṭatī’’ti (mahāva. aṭṭha. 295). Nisādanaṃ pavisanaṃ sannivesanaṃ nisādo, gunnaṃ viya nisādo etissāti gonisādi. Bhikkhuṃ ṭhapetvā sesasahadhammikā sabbe ca devamanussā idha gahapatīti sāmaññena adhippetā. Ettha pana gahapatisambandhinī kuṭi dīghena gahapatī.
依注释书里“然而,在不允许的地方,在能共宿的房屋中住过”这句话可知,僧团所想要的精舍、半屋、楼阁、殿堂、洞窟、岩窟等,也应当知道这些是通称;具备各自特征、能共宿的岩窟等,应当知道都归入这四种屋之中。在这四种能共宿的地方,属于僧团或属于个人的、或属于比丘所有的住处,即使未受具足戒的人在里面住了一夜,在里面煮了时分食和夜分食,也不算入“中住中煮”,更何况其余两种。然而,即使在不允许的地方,住过和煮过也是允许的,所以说“在其中住过、煮过都允许”。巴利
‘‘Yaṃ pana akappiyabhūmiyaṃ sahaseyyappahonake gehe vuttha’’nti (mahāva. aṭṭha. 295) aṭṭhakathāvacanato yaṃ saṅgho ākaṅkhati vihāraṃ vā aḍḍhayogaṃ vā pāsādaṃ vā hammiyaṃ vā guhaṃ vā leṇādiṃ vā, tesampi sāmaññavacanaṃ viññāyatīti taṃtaṃlakkhaṇappattā sahaseyyappahonakā leṇādayo catūsveva kuṭīsu antogadhāti veditabbaṃ. Imāsu catūsu sahaseyyappahonake padese yaṃ saṅghikaṃ puggalikaṃ vā bhikkhusantakaṃ ekarattampi antovutthaṃ anupasampannena pakkañca yāvakālikaṃ yāmakālikañca antovutthaantopakkasaṅkhaṃ na gacchati, ko pana vādo itaradvaye. Taṃ pana akappiyabhūmiyampi vutthaṃ pakkañca vaṭṭati. Tena vuttaṃ ‘‘yāsu vutthaṃ pakkañca kappatī’’ti.
137 137. 对于为了居住而造的、属于僧团的或属于某一个人的、够两个人共宿的房屋,应当得到许可的小屋,这是前后关联。其中,“为了居住”这句话,排除了不是为了居住而造的房屋。“属于某一个人的”,是指属于一位比丘的财产。“许可的小屋”:这里的说明是以状态为重点,因为在房屋中再获得房屋并不合理,所以它的意思是“许可的小屋性”。不过,长音应按照偈颂的方式来理解,或者按照“许可的小屋性”这一修饰方式来理解。“够两个人共宿的”在这里,是指符合住所定义中所说的那种卧坐处。巴利
137. Vāsatthāya kate saṅghike vā ekasantake vā sahaseyyappahonake gehe kappiyākuṭi laddhabbāti sambandho. Tattha vāsatthāyāti iminā avāsatthāya kataṃ nivatteti. Ekasantaketi ekassa bhikkhuno santake. Kappiyākuṭīti bhāvappadhānoyaṃ niddeso, na hi gehe gehaṃ laddhuṃ yujjatīti kappiyakuṭitāti attho. Dīgho pana gāthāvasena, kappiyā kuṭitāti vā visesanavasena daṭṭhabbaṃ. Sahaseyyappahonaketi ettha sahaseyyappahonakaṃ vāsāgāralakkhaṇe vuttalakkhaṇaṃ senāsanaṃ.
138 现在,为了依次说明那些小屋,并说明在那里应当实行的规定,以及它们怎样被完全舍弃,所以说了“在房屋中”等话。其中,“我们造合法小屋,我们造合法小屋”,应当这样连接起来理解。砖和柱子,本来应该说成“砖柱”,这里把音缩短了。以砖柱等为开头的墙壁宫殿,这是多财释。后面加上“第一”这个词,就成了持业释。“若已放置,它便是告知终结的”,应当把“若”和“它”这两个词连接起来理解其含义。巴利
138. Idāni tā kuṭiyo kamena dassetvā tattha paṭipajjitabbavidhiṃ, tāsaṃ sabbathāpagamañca dassetuṃ ‘‘gehe’’tiādimāha. Tattha ‘‘kappiyakuṭiṃ karoma, kappiyakuṭiṃ karomā’’ti evamīrayanti sambandho. Iṭṭhakā ca thambhā ca ‘‘iṭṭhakāthambhā’’ti vattabbe rasso. Iṭṭhakathambhā ādi yassa bhittipāsādassāti bahubbīhi. Pacchā paṭhamasaddena kammadhārayo. ‘‘Ṭhapeyya ce, sā ussāvanantikā’’ti evaṃ ce-sā-sadde yojetvā attho veditabbo.
139 应当这样连接理解:即使整个园林都没有被围起来。无论住所是被围起来的,还是没有被围起来的,那都不是判断标准。巴利
139. Sakalo aparikkhitto ārāmopi vāti sambandho. Senāsanaṃ parikkhittaṃ vā hotu, aparikkhittaṃ vā, na taṃ pamāṇaṃ.
140 应这样理解:或者是别人为了作净屋而布施的,或者是属于他们自己的。巴利
140. Aññehi kappiyakuṭiyā atthāya dinno vā tesaṃ santako vāti yojanā.
141 以不违背的方式可以认为净的,就是净;净即能力,因此,在阴性词中加上“阿”后缀所构成的词形;不是净的就是不净,不净又是小屋,所以叫不净屋,就在那里面。“酥等”这个词涵盖了七日药和尽形寿药。巴利
141. Avirodhabhāvena kappanīyā kappā, kappa sāmatthiyamiccetasmā itthiyaṃ āpaccaye rūpaṃ, na kappā akappā, akappā ca sā kuṭi ceti akappakuṭi, tāya. Sappiādīti iminā sattāhakālikaṃ yāvajīvikañca gahitaṃ.
142 “以那些”:与在不净屋里存放过的酥等混在一起,因为和七日药相混,所以说“七日之内可以”。 “有食”:与称为食的前两种药合在一起。 “自煮性”:自己亲手煮的,就叫自煮;和七日药一起煮成的有食尽形寿药,它的状态就是自煮性。自己煮的,因为和自身混在一起,也使那食变成自煮那一类,因此它具有自煮性,这就是意趣所在。巴利
142.Tehevāti akappakuṭiyaṃ vutthasappiādīhi eva saddhiṃ sattāhakālikasaṃsaṭṭhatāya ‘‘sattāhaṃ kappate’’ti vuttaṃ. Sāmiseti āmisasaṅkhātena purimadvayena sahite. Sāmapākatāti sāmaṃ attanā pāko etassāti sāmapākaṃ, sattāhakālikena saha pakkaṃ sāmisaṃ yāvajīvikaṃ, tassa bhāvo sāmapākatā. Sayaṃ pakkaṃ taṃ attanā saṃsaṭṭhatāya tampi āmisaṃ sāmapākagatikaṃ karotīti tassa sāmapākatā hotīti adhippāyo.
143 已决意就是已确立。eva这个词应当放在tiṭṭhati这个词的后面来看。巴利
143.Adhiṭṭhitāti patiṭṭhitā. Eva-saddo tiṭṭhatisaddassa ante daṭṭhabbo.
144 “一切”是指在柱子等所有东西当中。所谓“已弃舍地的屋”,就是那块地已经被弃舍了的屋子。这里的关联是:在已围起来的范围内,属于“已弃舍地的屋”。“其余”是指另外两种屋子。“屋顶毁坏”是指屋顶的破坏。这里也同样要带上“已弃舍地的屋”来理解。巴利
144.Sabbesūti thambhādīsu sakalesu. Jahitaṃ vatthu kuṭibhūmi yassā jahitavatthukā. Parikkhitte jahitavatthukāti sambandho. Sesāti itarā dve kuṭiyo. Chadanavibbhamāti chadanassa vināsā. Etthāpi ‘‘jahitavatthukā’’ti ānetabbanti.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7