《大狮子吼经》注疏显示巴利原文
8. Mahāsīhanādasuttavaṇṇanā
裸形者迦叶事注疏显示巴利原文
Acelakassapavatthuvaṇṇanā
381 世尊当时所在的那座城市,其所在国名与城名相同,因此“uruññā”即指郁卢那国中名为郁卢那的城市。“Ramaṇīya”(令人愉悦):因该地风光怡人,树荫与水丰足,且远离人烟,故令人心旷神怡。“Nāma”指族姓。“Tapana”意为令身体灼热、烧炙、疲惫,此即是苦行(tapo);具足苦行,故称苦行僧(tapassī),指那位苦行者。因为这样的人依止苦行,或苦行依止于他,所以称为“tapanissitaka”(依止苦行者)。“Lūkhājīvī”:因缺少众人敬信之行,而活命粗劣、令人厌恶,指粗活命者。“Muttācārādi”中的“等”字,包含了此后巴利经文(《长部》1.397)所说的以手舔食等行为。“Uppaṇḍeti”:以嘲笑的方式辱骂。“Upavadati”:先以轻蔑的态度进行毁谤,故说“轻蔑、贬斥”。在“Dhammassa ca anudhammaṃ”此句中,“dha显示巴利原文
381. Yasmiṃ raṭṭhe taṃ nagaraṃ, tassa raṭṭhassapi yasmiṃ nagare tadā bhagavā vihāsi, tassa nagarassapi etadeva nāmaṃ, tasmā uruññāyanti uruññājanapade uruññāsaṅkhāte nagareti attho. Ramaṇīyoti manoharabhūmibhāgatāya chāyūdakasampattiyā, janavivittatāya ca manoramo. Nāmanti gottanāmaṃ. Tapanaṃ santapanaṃ kāyassa khedanaṃ tapo, so etassa atthīti tapassī, taṃ tapassiṃ. Yasmā tathābhūto tapaṃ nissito, tapo vā taṃ nissito, tasmā āha ‘‘tapanissitaka’’nti. Lūkhaṃ vā pharusaṃ sādhusammatācāravirahato napasādanīyaṃ ājīvati vattatīti lūkhājīvī, taṃ lūkhājīviṃ. Muttācārādīti ādi-saddena parato pāḷiyaṃ (dī. ni. 1.397) āgatā hatthāpalekhanādayo saṅgahitā. Uppaṇḍetīti uhasanavasena paribhāsati. Upavadatīti avaññāpubbakaṃ apavadati, tenāha ‘‘hīḷeti vambhetī’’ti. Dhammassa ca anudhammaṃti ettha dhammo nāma hetu ‘‘hetumhi ñāṇaṃ dhammapaṭisambhidā’’tiādīsu (vibha. 720) viyāti āha ‘‘kāraṇassa anukāraṇa’’nti. Kāraṇanti cettha tathāpavattassa saddassa attho adhippeto tassa pavattihetubhāvato. Atthappayutto hi saddappayogo. Anukāraṇanti ca so eva parehi tathā vuccamāno. Parehīti ‘‘ye te’’ti vuttasattehi parehi. Vuttakāraṇenāti yathā tehi vuttaṃ, tathā ce tumhehi na vuttaṃ, evaṃ sati tehi vuttakāraṇena sakāraṇo hutvā tumhākaṃ vādo vā tato paraṃ tassa anuvādo koci appamattakopi viññūhi garahitabbaṃ ṭhānaṃ kāraṇaṃ nāgaccheyya, kimevaṃ nāgacchatīti yojanā. ‘‘Idaṃ vuttaṃ hotī’’tiādinā tamevatthaṃ saṅkhepato dasseti.
382 接着,世尊针对分别论,先略说“他们并非如我所说”,进而加以分析显示,故说“迦叶,于此我……”等,再以分析的方式说明“于此,有一类……”等。世尊确实呵斥那种毫无意义、不导向止息烦恼的身体疲劳苦行,如说“自我折磨的修行是苦的、非圣的、与无义之集相连结”等(《相应部》3.1081;《大品》13;《无碍解道》2.30)。而对于有意义、导向止息的修行,他则加以赞叹,如说“是住林者,是著粪扫衣者”等。所谓少福者,即因缺乏福德,以邪见为主,否定业果,秉持“无布施”等邪见(《长部》1.171;《中部》1.445;2.94, 95, 225;3.91, 115;《相应部》3.210;《法集论》1221;《分别》938),以此圆满身语意三种恶行。以邪命为活:立足于欺诈,希图宣扬不实功德,以此邪命方式生活。这二者,便是被称为“少福者”与“有福者”的这两种造恶之人。显示巴利原文
382. Idāni yaṃ vibhajjavādaṃ sandhāya bhagavatā ‘‘na me te vuttavādino’’ti saṅkhepato vatvā taṃ vibhajitvā dassetuṃ ‘‘idhāhaṃ kassapā’’tiādi vuttaṃ, taṃ vibhāgena dassento ‘‘idhekacco’’tiādimāha . Bhagavā hi niratthakaṃ anupasamasaṃvattanikaṃ kāyakilamathaṃ ‘‘attakilamathānuyogo dukkho anariyo anatthasaṃhito’’tiādinā (saṃ. ni. 3.1081; mahāva. 13; paṭi. ma. 2.30) garahati. Sātthakaṃ pana upasamasaṃvattanikaṃ ‘‘āraññiko hoti, paṃsukūliko hotī’’tiādinā vaṇṇeti. Appapuññatāyāti apuññatāya. Tīṇi duccaritāni pūretvāti micchādiṭṭhibhāvato kammaphalaṃ paṭikkhipanto ‘‘natthi dinna’’ntiādinā (dī. ni. 1.171; ma. ni. 1.445; 2.94, 95, 225; 3.91, 115; saṃ. ni. 3.210; dha. sa. 1221; vibha. 938) micchādiṭṭhiṃ purakkhatvā tathā tathā tīṇi duccaritāni pūretvā. Anesanavasenāti kohaññe ṭhatvā asantaguṇasambhāvanicchāya micchājīvavasena. Ime dveti ‘‘appapuñño puññavā’’ti ca vutte duccaritakārino dve puggale sandhāya.
然而,就“此二者即是所指”这段而言,对于第二种情况,所说的“少福者、有福者”,应联系“善行者”等来理解。因为业论者正有这样两种人。同理,第一种和第二种情形中所说的方式,也当知适用于第三种和第四种情形中的关联。显示巴利原文
‘‘Imedve sandhāyā’’ti ettha pana dutiyanaye ‘‘appapuñño, puññavā’’ti ca vutte sucaritakārinoti ādinā yojetabbaṃ. Kammakiriyavādino hi ime dve puggalā. Iti paṭhamadutiyanayesu vuttanayeneva tatiyacatutthanayesu yojanā veditabbā.
“行外道行者”:指遵行外道的行为,并非解脱之行。“以自身安乐”:以不如法的快乐让自己安乐,因此说“圆满诸恶行后”。这是依“如今没有与我相等者”等想法,凭藉三种慢而说恶行的圆满。“以邪见力”:依凭“于诸欲中并无过失”这种生起的邪见之力。对出家女:即对已出家修苦行的女子;对年轻者:即对年少之人;对柔嫩者:即对纤细柔弱者;对毛稀者:即对毛发稀薄、呈铜色者。“于诸欲”:指所依欲(物质对象)。“Pātabyataṃ”:应受用之物,或已成就的受用。“Āpajjanto”:从事、靠近。此处“pā”一词有受用义,而“tabba”词表示作者成就之义,意为随自己的喜好去受用。因为即使是烦恼欲在受用时,也必然附着于所依欲之中。显示巴利原文
Bāhirakācārayutto titthiyācārayutto, na vimuttācāro. Attānaṃ sukhetvāti adhammikena sukhena attānaṃ sukhetvā, tenāha ‘‘duccaritāni pūretvā’’ti. ‘‘Na dāni mayā sadiso atthī’’tiādinā tissannaṃ maññanānaṃ vasena duccaritapūraṇamāha. Micchādiṭṭhivasenāti ‘‘natthi kāmesu doso’’ti evaṃ pavattamicchādiṭṭhivasena. Paribbājikāyāti pabbajjaṃ upagatāya tāpasadārikāya. Daharāyāti taruṇāya. Mudukāyāti sukhumālāya. Lomasāyāti tanutambalomatāya appalomāya. Kāmesūti vatthukāmesu. Pātabyatanti paribhuñjitabbaṃ, pātabyatanti vā paribhuñjanakataṃ. Āpajjantoti upagacchanto. Paribhogattho hi ayaṃ pā-saddo, kattusādhano ca tabba-saddo, yathāruci paribhuñjantoti attho. Kilesakāmopi hi assādiyamāno vatthukāmantogadhoyeva.
“Idaṃ”:指以上所说的这些义理分类。因为注释中是依外道的说法而作此分别的。“即使于教法中”:意即于此佛教教法中也是如此。显示巴利原文
Idanti yathāvuttaṃ atthappabhedaṃ vibhajjanaṃ. Titthiyavasena āgataṃ aṭṭhakathāyaṃ tathā vibhattattā. Sāsanepīti imasmiṃ sāsanepi.
于自身中,将本来不存在的阿拉汉果虚妄地宣称“我有”之后,便行近耳私语、受用资具、依止威仪——这是三种诈骗事。“如彼者”:即通过受持头陀支而成为粗活命者的人。“我将成为难得快乐之人”:意思是将会在恶趣中再生。显示巴利原文
Arahattaṃvā attani asantaṃ ‘‘atthī’’ti vippaṭijānitvā. Sāmantajappanaṃ, paccayapaṭisevanaṃ, iriyāpathanissitanti imāni tīṇi vā kuhanavatthūni. Tādisovāti dhutaṅga- (mi. pa. 4.2; visuddhi. 1.22) samādānavasena lūkhājīvī eva. Dullabhasukho bhavissāmi duggatīsu upapattiyāti adhippāyo.
383 “从某处”:指从某个“有”(生存界)而来。“Āgatā”:因结生而来到这里。“Idāni gantabbaṭṭhānaṃ”:未来结生之处。“Puna upapattiṃ”:在未来,从紧接着的“有”之后,是第三次结生;“再再生”即一次又一次地结生。“以何原因?”:不如实了知的人,随欲贪和瞋恚而责备任何事物;我既如实了知,又依何原因去责备那些呢?其实并没有这样的原因——这是他想要表达的意思,因此他说“唯是应呵责者”等。“Tamatthaṃ”:即对应当呵责的加以呵责,对应当赞叹的加以赞叹。显示巴利原文
383.Asukaṭṭhānatoti asukabhavato. Āgatāti nibbattanavasena idhāgatā. Idāni gantabbaṭṭhānanti āyatiṃ nibbattanaṭṭhānaṃ. Puna upapattinti āyatiṃ anantarabhavato tatiyaṃ upapattiṃ, puna upapattīti punappunaṃ nibbatti. Kena kāraṇenāti yathābhūtaṃ ajānanto hi icchādosavasena yaṃ kiñci garaheyya, ahaṃ pana yathābhūtaṃ jānanto sabbaṃ taṃ kena kāraṇena garahissāmi, taṃ kāraṇaṃ natthīti adhippāyo, tenāha ‘‘garahitabbamevā’’tiādi. Tamatthanti garahitabbasseva garahaṇaṃ, pasaṃsitabbassa ca pasaṃsanaṃ.
没有人会说“不好”:由于它能成就现法利益与来世利益,其运作本身就是善的,因此称为好的象乘。“五种怨”:指杀生等五种怨敌。因为这五种是五种戒的敌人,又是导致众生怨恨的原因,所以称为“怨”。正因如此,没有人会说它“善”;同样地,因为它不能成就现法利益等,而且会毁坏众生的善性。“不应抑制”:在执取色时,不应该去抑制。因为他们以为:得到眼睛正是为了见到美丽的事物。从他们觉得“于五门中不抑制是善”的那刻起,在这些地方实行抑制就成了不善——所以接着说:“再者,他们凡有某些……,于五门中的抑制”。显示巴利原文
Na koci ‘‘na sādhū’’ti vadati diṭṭhadhammikassa, samparāyikassa ca atthassa sādhanavaseneva pavattiyā bhaddakattā. Pañcavidhaṃ veranti pāṇātipātādipañcavidhaṃ veraṃ. Tañhi pañcavidhassa sīlassa paṭisattubhāvato, sattānaṃ verahetutāya ca ‘‘vera’’nti vuccati. Tato eva taṃ na koci ‘‘sādhū’’ti vadati, tathā diṭṭhadhammikādiatthānaṃ asādhanato, sattānaṃ sādhubhāvassa ca dūsanato. Na nirundhitabbanti rūpaggahaṇe na nivāretabbaṃ. Dassanīyadassanattho hi cakkhupaṭilābhoti tesaṃ adhippāyo. Yadaggena tesaṃ pañcadvāre asaṃvaro sādhu , tadaggena tattha saṃvaro na sādhūti āha ‘‘puna yaṃ te ekaccanti pañcadvāre saṃvara’’nti.
或者,有些外道——即前面所说的“那些沙门、婆罗门”——将自我折磨等苦行说成是“善”,我们却说那不是“善”。而他们认为是“不善”的,诸如无过失的资具受用、整齐穿着衣物等正行,我们却称赞那是“善”。这里的义理应当如此理解。显示巴利原文
Atha vā yaṃ te ekaccaṃ vadanti ‘‘sādhū’’ti te ‘‘eke samaṇabrāhmaṇā’’ti vuttā titthiyā yaṃ attakilamathānuyogādiṃ ‘‘sādhū’’ti vadanti, mayaṃ taṃ na ‘‘sādhū’’ti vadāma. Yaṃ te ekaccaṃ vadanti ‘‘na sādhū’’ti yaṃ pana te anavajjapaccayaparibhogaṃ, sunivatthasupārupanādisammāpaṭipattiñca ‘‘na sādhū’’ti vadanti, taṃ mayaṃ ‘‘sādhū’’ti vadāmāti evaṃ pettha attho veditabbo.
前面已以他派观点为基础展示了四组,现在再把这四组转成自派观点的依据而加以说明,因此开示了“evaṃ”等语。凡与此相同者,即以相同的方式说明为相同;不同者亦复如是。所谓“相等与不相等”(samānāsamānatā),仅仅指相等和不相等的情形。因为在自派教义中,可见应断除的诸法被无余断除,他派则无;同样,应成就的诸法也唯有在自派教义中才能圆满成就,他派则无。所以他接着说出了“tyāhaṃ”等语。显示巴利原文
Evaṃ yaṃ paravādamūlakaṃ catukkaṃ dassitaṃ, tadeva puna sakavādamūlakaṃ katvā dassitanti pakāsento ‘‘eva’’ntiādimāha. Yañhi kiñci kenaci samānaṃ, tenapi taṃ samānameva, tathā asamānaṃ pīti. Samānāsamānatanti samānāsamānatāmattaṃ. Anavasesato hi pahātabbānaṃ dhammānaṃ pahānaṃ sakavāde dissati, na paravāde. Tathā paripuṇṇameva ca upasampādetabbadhammānaṃ upasampādanaṃ sakavāde, na paravāde. Tena vuttaṃ ‘‘tyāha’’ntiādi.
质问论的解释(Samanuyuñjāpanakathāvaṇṇanā)显示巴利原文
Samanuyuñjāpanakathāvaṇṇanā
385 “问见解者”(Laddhiṃ pucchanto),即这样问:“乔达摩沙门是否无余断除染污法而住?还是其他教团之师?请你先在这里说出你自己的见解。”这便是问见解。“问原因者”(Kāraṇaṃ pucchanto),即当对方说“乔达摩沙门无余断除染污法而住”之后,接着问:“你是根据什么原因而明白这个道理的?”这便是问原因。“问二者者”(Ubhayaṃ pucchanto),即先说出原因:“这便是这里的原因”,然后在所承诺的道理得到证明时,为了从正推和反推两方面成立原因,就相似与不相似的分类,进一步询问譬喻和例证二者;这样问二者,并且原因具足三相,在所承诺的道理被证成后,再如实地、毫不延迟地阐述并作出结论,这就称为“质问”(samanubhāsati)。“归纳”(upasaṃharitvā),即提出之后。“以什么……”等,是显示归纳的方式。“第二句”(Dutiyapade),即在“以僧团或僧”这一句中。显示巴利原文
385.Laddhiṃpucchantoti ‘‘kiṃ samaṇo gotamo saṃkilesadhamme anavasesaṃ pahāya vattati, udāhu pare gaṇācariyā. Ettha tāva attano laddhiṃ vadā’’ti laddhiṃ pucchanto. Kāraṇaṃ pucchantoti ‘‘samaṇo gotamo saṃkilesadhamme anavasesaṃ pahāya vattatī’’ti vutte ‘‘kena kāraṇena evamatthaṃ gāhayā’’ti kāraṇaṃ pucchanto. Ubhayaṃ pucchantoti ‘‘idaṃ nāmettha kāraṇa’’nti kāraṇaṃ vatvā paṭiññāte atthe sādhiyamāne anvayato, byatirekato ca kāraṇaṃ samatthetuṃ sadisāsadisabhedaṃ upamodāharaṇadvayaṃ pucchanto, ubhayaṃ pucchanto kāraṇassa ca tilakkhaṇasampattiyā yathāpaṭiññāte atthe sādhite sammadeva anupacchā bhāsanto nigamento samanubhāsati nāma. Upasaṃharitvāti upanetvā. ‘‘Kiṃ te’’tiādi upasaṃharaṇākāradassanaṃ. Dutiyapadeti ‘‘saṅghena vā saṅgha’’nti imasmiṃ pade.
“Tamattha”(彼义),指应断除的诸法被无余断除而转起之义,以及应受持的诸法被无余受持而转起之义。将它与不善等词结合之后:由于从不善巧所生之义,所以称为“不善”(akusalā),而且这些法本身就叫作不善。其中前一词是指纯粹的不善,后一词是指与它同时生起的法以及属于它那一类别的法。因此说:“分作部分而放置”(koṭṭhāsaṃ vā katvā ṭhapitā),即把它们确定为不善的类别,这便是它的意思。由于“有罪过”的含义是“有过失”,并且与“应受责备”是同义词,所以这样说:“sāvajjāti sadosā”(有罪过即有过失)。所谓“圣”,本来就是没有过失的。可是这些法在任何时候都有过失,所以从“没有过失”这个意义来说,它们没有能力、也不能被称为圣。显示巴利原文
Tamatthanti taṃ pahātabbadhammānaṃ anavasesaṃ pahāya vattanasaṅkhātañca samādātabbadhammānaṃ anavasesaṃ samādāya vattanasaṅkhātañca atthaṃ. Yojetvāti akusalādipadehi yojetvā. Akosallasambhūtaṭṭhena akusalā ceva tatoyeva akusalāti ca saṅkhaṃ gatāti saṅkhātā tattha purimapadena ekantākusale vadati, dutiyapadena taṃsahagate, taṃpakkhiye ca, tenāha ‘‘koṭṭhāsaṃ vā katvā ṭhapitā’’ti, akusalapakkhiyabhāvena vavatthāpitāti attho. Avajjaṭṭho dosaṭṭho gārayhapariyāyattāti āha ‘‘sāvajjāti sadosā’’ti. Ariyā nāma niddosā, ime pana katthacipi niddosā na hontīti niddosaṭṭhena ariyā bhavituṃ nālaṃ asamatthā.
386-392 “Yanti”(他们去)在此处是表示原因、与主语同格的词,故说“yena viññū”(由它,智者们……)。而“Yaṃ vā panā”等,即“yaṃ pana kiñcī”(不管什么),乃是一种表示不以为然的表达,故说“yaṃ vā taṃ vā appamattakaṃ”(任何一点点微小的)。教团之师(gaṇācariyā)指富兰那等。由于僧团以佛陀为根本而生,因此通过僧团的成就也能彰显佛陀的成就,所以说“赞叹僧团时,便成就了对佛陀的赞叹”。赞叹是以净信为因的,为了以净信为切入点来显示此理,便说了“pasīdamānāpi hī”(因为即使正在净信者……)等句。其中的“pi”(即使)一词应这样理解:正如从正面可以累积赞叹,同样地,若佛陀的行持有偏差,便会导致弟子们不信;若弟子的行持有偏差,也会导致对佛陀的不信,这不信同样会累积。“身相成就”(sarīrasampatti),指容色成就,即色身的圆满。他们会成为依外貌衡量者,也会依音声、依法来衡量。显示巴利原文
386-392.Yanti kāraṇe etaṃ paccattavacananti āha ‘‘yena viññū’’ti. Yaṃ vā panāti ‘‘yaṃ pana kiñcī’’ti asambhāvanavacanametanti āha ‘‘yaṃ vā taṃ vā appamattaka’’nti. Gaṇācariyā pūraṇādayo. Satthuppabhavattā saṅghassa saṅghasampattiyāpi satthusampatti vibhāvīyatīti āha ‘‘saṅghapasaṃsāyapi satthuyeva pasaṃsāsiddhito’’ti. Sā pana pasaṃsā pasādahetukāti pasādamukhena taṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘pasīdamānāpi hī’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha pi-saddena yathā anvayato pasaṃsā samuccīyati, evaṃ satthuvippaṭipattiyā sāvakesu, sāvakavippaṭipattiyā ca satthari appasādo samuccīyatīti daṭṭhabbaṃ. Sarīrasampattinti rūpasampattiṃ, rūpakāyapāripūrinti attho. Bhavanti vattāro rūpappamāṇā , ghosadhammappamāṇā ca. Puna bhavanti vattāroti dhammappamāṇavaseneva yojetabbaṃ. Yā saṅghassa pasaṃsāti ānetvā sambandho.
其中,佛陀及佛弟子所独有、他人所无的可赞之处,已予以阐明。为了通过“远离”、“断除”、“律仪”、“诵出”的方式将其引出并显示,故说“这是用意所在”等语。在此,“断桥离”即指“圣道离”。“唯以观见的方式”,是仅以“无常”、“苦”等种种观察的方式进行,而非先确立名色、把握缘之后,再以三相安立而全面观照诸行。“其余者”指的是断除、止息、出离这三种断。“其余”是指除了五戒之外的一切戒律制御;如“他是堪忍的”等(《中部》等)所说,极为清净的安忍律仪;如“由慧抑制这些”所说,能断烦恼的道智,即名为智律仪;以闭护意等六根门而行持的清净根律仪;如“为令未生起的恶不善法不生”等(《长部》、《中部》、《相应部》、《分别论》)所说的正勤,名为精进律仪。关于这五种律仪,他说:“又,确实这五种巴帝摩卡的诵出……”等,这是为了显示教法中戒的殊胜繁多,进而说明他人只安住于其中一部分而已,此处再次指向前述的戒律制御。显示巴利原文
Tattha yā buddhānaṃ, buddhasāvakānaṃyeva ca pāsaṃsatā, aññesañca tadabhāvo jotito, taṃ viratippahānasaṃvaruddesavasena nīharitvā dassetuṃ ‘‘ayamadhippāyo’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Tattha setughātavirati nāma ariyamaggavirati. Vipassanāmattavasenāti ‘‘anicca’’nti vā ‘‘dukkha’’nti vā vividhaṃ dassanamattavasena, na pana nāmarūpavavatthānapaccayapariggaṇhanapubbakaṃ lakkhaṇattayaṃ āropetvā saṅkhārānaṃ sammasanavasena. Itarānīti samucchedapaṭippassaddhinissaraṇappahānāni. ‘‘Sesa’’nti pañcasīlato añño sabbo sīlasaṃvaro, ‘‘khamo hotī’’tiādinā (ma. ni. 1.24; 3.159; a. ni. 4.114) vutto suparisuddho khantisaṃvaro, ‘‘paññāyete pidhiyyare’’ti (su. ni. 1041; cūḷani. 60) evaṃ vutto kilesānaṃ samucchedako maggañāṇasaṅkhāto ñāṇasaṃvaro, manacchaṭṭhānaṃ indriyānaṃ pidahanavasena pavatto parisuddho indriyasaṃvaro, ‘‘anuppannānaṃ pāpakānaṃ akusalānaṃ dhammānaṃ anuppādāyā’’tiādinā (dī. ni. 2.402; ma. ni. 1.135; saṃ. ni. 5.8; vibha. 205) vutto sammappadhānasaṅkhāto vīriyasaṃvaroti imaṃ saṃvarapañcakaṃ sandhāyāha. Pañca kho panime pātimokkhuddesātiādi sāsane sīlassa bahubhāvaṃ dassetvā tadekadese eva paresaṃ avaṭṭhānadassanatthaṃ yathāvuttasīlasaṃvarasseva puna gahaṇaṃ.
圣八支道注释显示巴利原文
Ariyaaṭṭhaṅgikamaggavaṇṇanā
393 “狮子吼”意为最胜之声、无畏之声、不为任何人所退转之声。“我此所说之义不颠倒,其不颠倒性,应由修习此道后、不依凭他人而了知。”如此说,是为了令人觉悟其不颠倒性。在“有,迦叶,此道”等文中,沙门乔达摩于恰当的时机宣说此道,他依事实而说,故是“真实”;此道一向带来利益安乐,故是“有义”;不偏离法,故是“法”;与调伏相应、能调伏他人,故是“律”。他将亲自证知:“有我自身证知、亲证之后所开示的、能出离整个轮回之苦的道,迦叶,以及成就此道的方便——前分道。”如此结合,说明了:“沙门乔达摩依这些法……”这样的言论不为任何人所动摇,乃是如实的狮子吼。显示巴利原文
393.Sīhanādanti seṭṭhanādaṃ, abhītanādaṃ kenaci appaṭivattiyanādanti attho. ‘‘Ayaṃ yathāvutto mama vādo aviparīto, tassa aviparītabhāvo imaṃ maggaṃ paṭipajjitvā aparappaccayato jānitabbo’’ti evaṃ aviparītabhāvāvabodhanatthaṃ. ‘‘Atthi kassapā’’tiādīsu yaṃ maggaṃ paṭipanno samaṇo gotamo vadanto yuttapattakāle, tathabhāvato bhūtaṃ, ekaṃsato hitāvihabhāvena atthaṃ, dhammato anapetattā dhammaṃ, vinayayogato paresaṃ vinayanato ca vinayaṃ vadatīti sāmaṃyeva attapaccakkhatova jānissati, so mayā sayaṃ abhiññā sacchikatvā pavedito sakalavaṭṭadukkhanissaraṇabhūto atthi kassapa maggo, tassa ca adhigamūpāyabhūtā pubbabhāgapaṭipadāti ayamettha yojanā. Tena ‘‘samaṇo gotamo ime dhamme’’tiādinayappavatto vādo kenaci asaṃkampiyo yathābhūtasīhanādoti dasseti.
如‘他以正慧如实见……’(《增支部》等)所明,为将道与行道合为一处而显示,故说‘唯此’。‘唯此’一语,旨在遮止道的多种性,显示其为一切圣者所共有,并在教法中昭然显著。因此说:‘比丘们,此是唯一之道……’(《长部》《中部》《相应部》),以及‘此即是道,别无其他能令见解清净。’(《法句》)显示巴利原文
‘‘Evametaṃ yathābhūtaṃ sammappaññāya passatī’’tiādīsu (a. ni. 3.134) viya maggañca paṭipadañca ekato katvā dassento. ‘‘Ayamevā’’ti vacanaṃ maggassa puthubhāvapaṭikkhepanatthaṃ, sabbaariyasādhāraṇabhāvadassanatthaṃ, sāsane pākaṭabhāvadassanatthañca. Tenāha ‘‘ekāyano ayaṃ bhikkhave maggo’’ti, (dī. ni. 2.373; ma. ni. 1.106; saṃ. ni. 5.367, 384, 409)‘‘eseva maggo natthañño dassanassa visuddhiyā’’ti (dha. pa. 274),
唯此一道,见生灭尽头者,
心怀利益与悲悯者,了知此道;
过去,他们凭此道渡越;
现在及未来渡越暴流者,亦凭此渡越。
显示巴利原文 ‘‘Ekāyanaṃ jātikhayantadassī, Maggaṃ pajānāti hitānukampī; Etena maggena tariṃsu pubbe, Tarissanti ye ca taranti ogha’’nti. (saṃ. ni. 5.384, 409; mahāni. 191; cūḷani. 107, 121; netti. 170);
在一切经句与阿毗达摩句之中,唯有此道明确清晰、已被善加阐明,且一直传承至今。显示巴利原文
Sabbesu suttapadesesu abhidhammapadesesu ca ekovāyaṃ maggo pākaṭo paññāto āgato cāti.
《苦行精进论》的注释显示巴利原文
Tapopakkamakathāvaṇṇanā
394 苦行本身应当精勤努力、应当从事,故称“苦行精进”(tapopakkama),因此他说“tapārambhā”即“苦行之始”。这里的“ārambhana”正是“作”的意思,所以他说“tapokammāni”即是此义。“沙门业”是指沙门所应作的业。“Niccola”(裸体者)指舍弃衣物之人,或全然拒绝一切衣服之人。因受持裸体外道的禁戒而成为裸体。“站着大小便”等仅是举例,因为诸如呕吐后漱口等日常威仪也同样被他舍弃。他不用手舔手,因为不用水清洗。第二种情况也是同样的道理。当对他说“来,尊者”时,那种允许靠近的仪式称为“ehibhaddanta”(善来者式),行持此仪的人称为“ehibhaddantika”(善来者行者),而他拒绝此仪,故是“非善来者行者”。他之所以不行此仪,心中想:“身为沙门,不应成为听从他人话语而行动的人。”“Puretaraṃ”(更早)指比他本人到达该地之前的时间。据说,他这样想:“所谓比丘,应随自己的意愿去乞食。显示巴利原文
394. Tapoyeva upakkamitabbato ārabhitabbato tapopakkamoti āha ‘‘tapārambhā’’ti. Ārambhanañcettha karaṇamevāti āha ‘‘tapokammānītiattho’’ti. Samaṇakammasaṅkhātāti samaṇehi kattabbakammasaññitā. Niccoloti nissaṭṭhacelo sabbena sabbaṃ paṭikkhittacelo. Naggiyavatasamādānena naggo. ‘‘Ṭhitakova uccāraṃ karotī’’tiādi nidassanamattaṃ, vamitvā mukhavikkhālanādiācārassapi tena vissaṭṭhattā. Jivhāya hatthaṃ apalikhati apalihati udakena adhovanato. Dutiyavikappepi eseva nayo. ‘‘Ehi bhaddante’’ti vutte upagamanasaṅkhāto vidhi ehibhaddanto, taṃ caratīti ehibhaddantiko, tappaṭikkhepena na ehibhaddantiko. Na karoti samaṇena nāma parassa vacanakarena na bhavitabbanti adhippāyena. Puretaranti taṃ ṭhānaṃ attano upagamanato puretaraṃ. Taṃ kira so ‘‘bhikkhunā nāma yādicchakī eva bhikkhā gahetabbā’’ti adhippāyena na gaṇhāti. Uddissakataṃ ‘‘mama nimittabhāvena bahū khuddakā pāṇā saṅghātaṃ āpāditā’’ti na gaṇhāti. Nimantanaṃ na sādiyati ‘‘evaṃ tesaṃ vacanaṃ kataṃ bhavissatī’’ti. Kumbhīādīsupi so sattasaññīti āha ‘‘kumbhīkaḷopiyo’’tiādi.
“Kabaḷantarāyo”指的是对饭团的障碍。“saṅkitti”(共称)是指通过村庄共聚等方式聚集并称扬,同样也指收集起来的米粒等的堆聚。这里的“人们”是指那些从事服务的人。显示巴利原文
Kabaḷantarāyoti kabaḷassa antarāyo hotīti. Gāmasabhāgādivasena saṅgamma kittenti etissāti saṅkitti, tathā saṃhaṭataṇḍulādisañcayo. Manussāti veyyāvaccakaramanussā.
唯饮用具有迷醉特征的酒,才叫饮用“surā”(谷酒);而这里以“surā”一词亦包含了“meraya”(麦酒)。只向一家乞食之人,称为“一家行者”(ekāgārika)。仅以一只钵维持生活之人,称为“一钵行者”(ekālopika)。通过那个钵来施与,故称“datti”,它指的是仅能容纳一两个饭团的小型乞食容器,因此说“小钵”。以不进食而言,他有一日的间隔,故称“一日者”(ekāhika),他的食物即称为“一日食”。这一日食,实际含义便是隔日一食,因此说“隔一日者”。“二日者”等,也是同理。一日不食,一日进食,称为“一日轮”;这实际上即是一日者。二日不食,二日进食,称为“二日轮”。其余两种也是如此。不过,最高类型是“轮替食者”:二日不食,仅进食一日。其余两种亦是如此。显示巴利原文
Surāpānamevāti majjalakkhaṇappattāya surāya pānameva surāggahaṇena cettha merayampi saṅgahitaṃ. Ekāgārameva uñchatīti ekāgāriko. Ekālopeneva vattatīti ekālopiko. Dīyati etāyāti datti, dvattiālopamattagāhi khuddakaṃ bhikkhādānabhājanaṃ, tenāha ‘‘khuddakapātī’’ti. Abhuñjanavasena eko aho etassa atthīti ekāhiko, āhāro. Taṃ ekāhikaṃ, so pana atthato ekadivasalaṅghakoti āha ‘‘ekadivasantarika’’nti. ‘‘Dvīhika’’ntiādīsupi eseva nayo. Ekāhaṃ abhuñjitvā ekāhaṃ bhuñjanaṃ ekāhavāro, taṃ ekāhikameva atthato. Dvīhaṃ abhuñjitvā dvīhaṃ bhuñjanaṃ dvīhavāro. Sesadvayepi eseva nayo. Ukkaṭṭho pana pariyāyabhattabhojaniko dvīhaṃ abhuñjitvā ekāhameva bhuñjati. Sesadvayepi eseva nayo.
395 “Kuṇḍaka”指较细的碎米粒。显示巴利原文
395.Kuṇḍakanti tanutaraṃ taṇḍulasakalaṃ.
396 “Sāṇāni”指用麻丝与麻絮制成的衣物,也就是麻衣。“Missasāṇāni”是混合而成的麻衣,即粗麻衣,不是破布。以“伊拉草等”中的“等”字,涵盖了阿迦草、卡支草、达利草等。因为由伊拉草等制成的衣物,实为粗劣鄙陋的衣服,故应如此说。显示巴利原文
396. Saṇehi saṇavākehi nibbattavatthāni sāṇāni. Missasāṇāni masāṇāni, na bhaṅgāni. Erakatiṇādīnīti ādi-saddena akkamakacikadalīvākādīnaṃ saṅgaho. Erakādīhi katāni hi chavāni lāmakāni dussānīti vattabbataṃ labhanti.
由于他是以邪精进之力修习蹲踞苦行,所以说“从事蹲踞精进”(ukkuṭikavīriyaṃ anuyutto)。“Thaṇḍila”指平坦的自然地面,正如经中说“出现在平坦地面”等处所表明的那样,因此“thaṇḍilaseyya”(露地坐)即指在无遮蔽的自然地面上睡觉的意思。“Laddhaṃ āsanaṃ”指为了坐下而随意获得的任何座位。“Akopetvā”意为不离去,因此说“他便习惯于就在那里坐着”(tattheva nisīdanasīlo)。由于他既不丢弃也不舍弃那个座位,所以称为“不破坏”(akopento)。“Vikaṭa”是指粪便,因住处等因缘而变得异样,故得此称。显示巴利原文
Micchāvāyāmavaseneva ukkuṭikavatānuyogoti āha ‘‘ukkuṭikavīriyaṃ anuyutto’’ti. Thaṇḍilanti vā samā pakatibhūmi vuccati ‘‘patthaṇḍile pāturahosī’’tiādīsu (ma. ni. 4.10) viya, tasmā thaṇḍilaseyyanti anantarahitāya pakatibhūmiyaṃ seyyanti vuttaṃ hoti. Laddhaṃ āsananti nisīdituṃ yathāladdhaṃ āsanaṃ. Akopetvāti aññattha anupagantvā, tenāha ‘‘tattheva nisīdanasīlo’’ti. So hi taṃ achaḍḍento apariccajanto akopento nāma hoti. Vikaṭanti gūthaṃ vuccati āsayavasena virūpaṃ jātanti katvā.
在此,从“成为裸形者”等苦行条目,乃至“不饮谷糠水”,这些皆为一次性受持的条目。而“为一家食者”等,则是多种选项,或为不同时节的受持。同样地,“食野菜者”等,以及“亦着麻衣”等也是如此。因为此处用了“或”字,也用了“亦”字。其中的“亦”字亦应理解为表示选择关系。然而在前述那些条目中,并未如此使用。作如是安立之后,于宣说“成为裸形者”之后,再说“亦着麻衣”等;于宣说“持尘垢者”之后,再说“从事水浴修行”等,便无矛盾。再者,于此何必纠结有矛盾与否呢?因为外道自身的言论,本就如同疯人所编之篓筐般混乱。或者亦可如此理解:这是从“成为裸形者”说起,顺势为显示一切自我折磨的修行方式,方接着宣说“亦着麻衣”等。显示巴利原文
Ettha ca ‘‘acelako hotī’’tiādīni vatapadāni yāva ‘‘na thusodakaṃ pivatī’’ti etāni ekavārāni. ‘‘Ekāgāriko vā’’tiādīni nānāvārāni, nānākālikāni vā. Tathā ‘‘sākabhakkho vā’’tiādīni, ‘‘sāṇānipi dhāretī’’tiādīni ca. Tathā hettha vā-saddaggahaṇaṃ, pi-saddaggahaṇañca kataṃ. Pi-saddopi vikappattho eva daṭṭhabbo. Purimesu pana na kataṃ. Evañca katvā ‘‘acelako hotī’’ti vatvā ‘‘sāṇānipi dhāretī’’tiādi vacanassa, ‘‘rajojalladharo hotī’’ti vatvā ‘‘udakorohanānuyogaṃ anuyutto’’ti vacanassa ca avirodho siddho hoti. Atha vā kimettha avirodhacintāya. Ummattakapacchisadiso hi titthiyavādo. Atha vā ‘‘acelako hotī’’ti ārabhitvā tappasaṅgena sabbampi attakilamathānuyogaṃ dassentena ‘‘sāṇānipi dhāretī’’tiādi vuttanti daṭṭhabbaṃ.
苦行无义论解说显示巴利原文
Tapopakkamaniratthakathāvaṇṇanā
397 “若无戒等成就”:意即若没有戒成就、定成就、慧成就这些出世间的成就,则任何时候都不可能有真正的沙门性,亦不可能有真正的婆罗门性;正因如此,故此处是为揭示那些苦行毫无意义。“离嗔与敌意”:这是就嗔与慈是直接对立而说的。或可理解为:以“嗔”一词涵盖一切与禅那相对立的杂染法,而以“敌意”一词指代成为敌人的那些众生。因为嗔心若无,敌意亦随之无存。显示巴利原文
397.Sīlasampadādīhi vināti sīlasampadā, samādhisampadā, paññāsampadāti imāhi lokuttarāhi sampadāhi vinā na kadāci sāmaññaṃ vā brahmaññaṃ vā sambhavati, yasmā ca tadevaṃ, tasmā tesaṃ tapopakkamānaṃ niratthakataṃ dassentoti yojanā. ‘‘Dosaveravirahita’’nti idaṃ dosassa mettāya ujupaṭipakkhatāya vuttaṃ. Dosa-ggahaṇena vā sabbepi jhānapaṭipakkhā saṃkilesadhammā gahitā, vera-ggahaṇena paccatthikabhūtā sattā. Yadaggena hi dosarahitaṃ, tadaggena verarahitanti.
398 “Pakati(自然)”:谓其以明显的方式令知、令通达,故称为“pakati”,此是世间通行的说法。因此说“pakati kho esā”,意指“这即是自然之论”。“Mattāyā(以量)”:“mattā”一词,如“以适度的乐舍”等句中,是将“少量”之义纳于其中,故成为表示限量的词,因此说“以此量,如此少许”。而依此限量所应断除的、随此论题而来的修行次第,即是“以修行次第”之义。“Sabbatthā(于一切处)”:指于一切处,即在所有场合。显示巴利原文
398. Pākaṭabhāvena kāyati gametīti pakati, lokasiddhavādo, tenāha ‘‘pakati kho esāti pakatikathā esā’’ti. Mattāyāti mattā-saddo ‘‘mattā sukhapariccāgā’’tiādīsu (dha. pa. 290) viya appatthaṃ antonītaṃ katvā pamāṇavācakoti āha ‘‘iminā pamāṇena evaṃ parittakenā’’ti. Tena pana pamāṇena pahātabbo pakaraṇappatto paṭipattikkamoti āha ‘‘paṭipattikkamenā’’ti. Sabbatthāti sabbavāresu.
399 “你们说别样”:若以裸形等方式便能真正成就沙门性、婆罗门性,那么沙门便极易辨识,婆罗门也极易辨识。然而,正因你们在此之外另立了一套关于沙门性与婆罗门性的说法,沙门才难以辨识,婆罗门也难以辨识。因此说“正是针对此点而说”。“在遮遣了那种自然论之后”:先前,心中怀着依自然力而成立的沙门性与婆罗门性,而说了“难作”等语,世尊也是针对那个,才说了“此是自然”等。但在这里,遮遣了那种自然论——也就是收回了关于自然沙门、自然婆罗门的论域之后,进而开显、阐明从自性上、从究竟义上,沙门与婆罗门是难以辨识的。“即使在那里”:在谈论沙门与婆罗门的语境中,也依着同样的方式理解。显示巴利原文
399.Aññathā vadathāti yadi acelakabhāvādinā sāmaññaṃ vā brahmaññaṃ vā abhavissa, suvijānova samaṇo suvijāno brāhmaṇo. Yasmā pana tumhe ito aññathāva sāmaññaṃ brahmaññañca vadatha, tasmā dujjānova samaṇo dujjāno brāhmaṇo, tenāha ‘‘idaṃ sandhāyāhā’’ti. Taṃ pakativādaṃ paṭikkhipitvāti pubbe yaṃ pākatikaṃ sāmaññaṃ brahmaññañca hadaye ṭhapetvā tena ‘‘dukkara’’ntiādi vuttaṃ, tameva sandhāya bhagavatāpi ‘‘pakati kho esā’’tiādi vuttaṃ. Idha pana taṃ pakativādaṃ pākatikasamaṇabrāhmaṇavisayaṃ kathaṃ paṭikkhipitvā paṭisaṃharitvā sabhāvatova paramatthatova samaṇassa brāhmaṇassa ca dujjānabhāvaṃ āvikaronto pakāsento. Tatrāpīti samaṇabrāhmaṇavādepi vuttanayeneva.
戒定慧成就解说显示巴利原文
Sīlasamādhipaññāsampadāvaṇṇanā
400-1 “贤者”:指具足由因缘成就的贤明智慧。他是如何领悟的呢?由于智慧成熟,犹如瓶中灯,以内在本具闪耀的慧明辨,于处处把握世尊所开示的义理,并将那教法受持于心。“对他”:即对那个从成为裸形者乃至从事水浴修行而住的人,我问那成就——意思就是“凭借哪些成就而成为沙门”等。“戒具足”:这里的 iti 字有“等”的含义,因此它也包含了“心具足”“慧具足”这两句。因为无学的戒蕴等三蕴所包含的正是阿拉汉果,所以他说“指的就是阿拉汉果而说”等。在这里,“此”是指这段话。显示巴利原文
400-1.Paṇḍitoti hetusampattisiddhena paṇḍiccena samannāgato, kathaṃ uggahesi paripakkañāṇattā ghaṭe padīpena viya abbhantare samujjalantena paññāveyyattiyena tattha tattha bhagavatā desitamatthaṃ pariggaṇhanto tampi desanaṃ upadhāresi. Tassa cāti yo acelako hoti yāva udakorohanānuyogaṃ anuyutto viharati, tassa ca. Tā sampattiyo pucchāmi, yāhi samaṇo ca hotīti adhippāyo. Sīlasampadāyāti iti-saddo ādiattho, tena ‘‘cittasampadāya paññāsampadāyā’’ti padadvayaṃ saṅgaṇhāti asekkhasīlādikhandhattayasaṅgahitañhi arahattaṃ, tenāha ‘‘arahattaphalameva sandhāya vutta’’ntiādi. Tattha idanti idaṃ vacanaṃ.
狮子吼论解说显示巴利原文
Sīhanādakathāvaṇṇanā
402 由于不与他人所共有,且以不与他人共有的意义为所行境界,故称为“无上”——正在发出佛陀的狮子吼。因为极度、最极清净,故称为“最极清净”。“最极”即殊胜,因此说为“最上”。“戒”就是指世间戒。就如世尊的出世间戒,由于具足宿习、摧破对立,而成为不与他人共有的无上;同样地,他的世间戒也依出世间戒相伴而生,因此说“倘若戒与我的戒相等,那就与我相等”——意思是相等、齐等、等同。而所谓的“凡此增上戒”,是把世间戒与出世间戒两者总摄在一起说的,因此说“在戒上也一样”。如此,这是关于戒的范畴。由于最先生起,故称为“初”。显示巴利原文
402. Anaññasādhāraṇatāya , anaññasādhāraṇatthavisayatāya ca anuttaraṃ buddhasīhanādaṃ nadanto. Ativiya accantavisuddhatāya paramavisuddhaṃ. Paramanti ukkaṭṭhaṃ, tenāha ‘‘uttama’’nti. Sīlameva lokiyasīlattā. Yathā anaññasādhāraṇaṃ bhagavato lokuttarasīlaṃ savāsanaṃ paṭipakkhaviddhaṃsanato, evaṃ lokiyasīlampi tassa anucchavikabhāvena sambhūtattā, samena samanti samasamanti ayamettha atthoti āha ‘‘mama sīlasamena sīlena mayā sama’’nti. ‘‘Yadidaṃ adhisīla’’nti lokiyaṃ, lokuttarañcāti duvidhampi buddhasīlaṃ ekajjhaṃ katvā vuttaṃ. Tenāha ‘‘sīlepī’’ti. Iti imanti evaṃ imaṃ sīlavisayaṃ. Paṭhamaṃ pavattattā paṭhamaṃ.
「热恼」即被燃烧、被破坏之意。「厌离」即轻蔑、视为低劣。圣者由于无过失,因而远离一切烦恼。将属于道果、称为精进的「苦行厌离」连接起来,所以有此关联。所谓「最胜」,乃于一切中最为殊胜。如同年轻的状态称为青春,厌离者的状态便称为「厌离性」。诸烦恼的断除与止息,即是「断与止息的解脱」。「出离的解脱」即是涅槃。又,由于正语等已为「增上戒」所摄,正精进已为「增上厌离」所摄,正见已为「增上慧」所摄,为将尚未摄尽者悉数摄入,属于道果的正思惟、正念与正定,也应视为「断与止息的解脱」。而出离的解脱则正是涅槃本身。显示巴利原文
Tapatīti santappati, vidhamatīti attho. Jigucchatīti hīḷeti lāmakato ṭhapeti. Niddosattā ariyā ārakā kilesehīti. Maggaphalasampayuttā vīriyasaṅkhātā tapojigucchāti ānetvā sambandho. Paramā nāma sabbukkaṭṭhabhāvato. Yathā yuvino bhāvo yobbanaṃ, evaṃ jigucchino bhāvo jegucchaṃ. Kilesānaṃ samucchindanapaṭippassambhanāni samucchedapaṭipassaddhivimuttiyo. Nissaraṇavimutti nibbānaṃ. Atha vā sammāvācādīnaṃ adhisīlaggahaṇena, sammāvāyāmassa adhijegucchaggahaṇena, sammādiṭṭhiyā adhipaññāggahaṇena gahitattā aggahitaggahaṇena sammāsaṅkappasatisamādhayo maggaphalapariyāpannā samucchedapaṭipassaddhivimuttiyo daṭṭhabbā. Nissaraṇavimutti pana nibbānameva.
403 任何远离人群之处,在此即指「空寂之处」。于彼处,若不出声则无声响,故说「独坐一处」。所谓「在八众中」,是指此八种大众:刹帝利众、婆罗门众、居士众、沙门众、四大王天众、三十三天众、魔众、梵天众。显示巴利原文
403. Yaṃ kiñci janavivittaṃ ṭhānaṃ idha ‘‘suññāgāra’’nti adhippetaṃ. Tattha nadantena vinā nādo natthīti āha ‘‘ekatova nisīditvā’’ti. Aṭṭhasu parisāsūti khattiyaparisā, brāhmaṇaparisā, gahapatiparisā, samaṇaparisā, cātumahārājikaparisā, tāvatiṃsaparisā, māraparisā, brahmaparisāti imāsu aṭṭhasu parisāsu.
「自信之处」:由于是无所畏惧的状态,乃智慧与力量成就的标志,从任何处皆不生惊惶,即无恐惧状态之意。「如公牛之处」指最殊胜之处、最上之处;或者,意指过去诸佛之处。显示巴利原文
Vesārajjānīti visāradabhāvā ñāṇappahānasampadānimittaṃ kutoci asantassanabhāvā nibbhayabhāvāti attho. Āsabhaṃ ṭhānanti seṭṭhaṃ ṭhānaṃ, uttamaṃ ṭhānanti attho. Āsabhā vā pubbabuddhā, tesaṃ ṭhānanti attho.
又,“属于公牛的”即是“如公牛般的”;“如公牛般的”意指如同公牛那样。正如被称为牛王的公牛,凭借自身力量四足踏地,以不动之姿安住;同样,如来具足十种如来力,以四无所畏之足镇伏八众之地,在有天神的世间中,不为任何敌人所动摇,以不动之姿安住。他如此安住,便宣称、确立、不否认那“如公牛般的地位”于自身,因此说“他宣称如公牛般的地位”。显示巴利原文
Apica usabhassa idanti āsabhaṃ, āsabhaṃ viyāti āsabhaṃ. Yathā hi nisabhasaṅkhāto usabho attano usabhabalena catūhi pādehi pathaviṃ uppīḷetvā acalaṭṭhānena tiṭṭhati, evaṃ tathāgatopi dasahi tathāgatabalehi samannāgato catūhi vesārajjapādehi aṭṭhaparisāpathaviṃ uppīḷetvā sadevake loke kenaci paccatthikena akampiyo acalena ṭhānena tiṭṭhati. Evaṃ tiṭṭhamānova taṃ āsabhaṃ ṭhānaṃ paṭijānāti upagacchati na paccakkhāti attani āropeti. Tena vuttaṃ ‘‘āsabhaṃ ṭhānaṃ paṭijānātī’’ti.
“作狮子吼”(sīhanādaṃ nadati):正如兽王由于能忍受种种危难、能击杀林中的水牛、醉象等,故被称为“狮子”;同样,如来由于能忍受世间法、能摧破外道之说,故也被称为“狮子”。以此所称之狮的吼声,即是狮子吼。其中,如同狮子具足狮子之力,于一切处无所畏惧、远离怖畏惊悚而作狮子吼;同样,如来狮子也具足十种如来力,在八众中无所畏惧、远离怖畏惊悚,以“如是色……”等种种庄严而作狮子吼。显示巴利原文
Sīhanādaṃ nadatīti yathā migarājā parissayānaṃ sahanato, vanamahiṃsamattavāraṇādīnaṃ hananato ca ‘‘sīho’’ti vuccati, evaṃ tathāgato lokadhammānaṃ sahanato, parappavādānaṃ hananato ca ‘‘sīho’’ti vuccati. Evaṃ vuttassa sīhassa nādaṃ sīhanādaṃ. Tattha yathā sīho sīhabalena samannāgato sabbattha visārado vigatalomahaṃso sīhanādaṃ nadati, evaṃ tathāgatasīhopi dasahi tathāgatabalehi samannāgato aṭṭhasu parisāsu visārado vigatalomahaṃso ‘‘iti rūpa’’ntiādinā (saṃ. ni. 3.78; a. ni. 8.2) nayena nānāvilāsasampannaṃ sīhanādaṃ nadati.
“造作问题”(pañhaṃ abhisaṅkharitvā)的意思是:依自智慧之力,善加构思所欲了知的意义;就在提问的那一刹那,即依处而生的辩才予以解答。他便令其心得满足,因为所答与希求相应。他们便认为“此是可听闻的”,因为除了八种无暇刹那之外,能在第九刹那获得。他们怀着“凡我师所说,我等皆当听闻”的敬重,以大热忱认为此应听闻、应接受。他们极为清净,因为净信增上,远离了垢染,心成为堪能、柔软。所谓“令净信者作供养”(pasannakāranti),即是对净信者所应施的恭敬,这是指以法供养和食供养而行供养的意思。在这里,为了显示食供养,而说“诸胜妙物……”等;而法供养则通过“为了真实”来显示。“为了真实”(tathābhāvāya),即是为了达成那样的状态——为令他们远离流转诸有之苦、成就说法的目的,而成就那样的状态。因此他说“为了圆满法随法行”。而这一法随法行,应当依照这样的次第去实践;对实践者来说,当内在因缘具足时,它的圆满是决定的。显示巴利原文
Pañhaṃ abhisaṅkharitvāti ñātuṃ icchitamatthaṃ attano ñāṇabalānurūpaṃ abhiracitvā taṅkhaṇaṃyevāti pucchitakkhaṇeyeva ṭhānuppattikapaṭibhānena vissajjeti. Cittaṃ paritosetiyeva ajjhāsayānurūpaṃ vissajjanato. Sotabbañcassa maññanti aṭṭhakkhaṇavajjitena navamena khaṇena labbhamānattā. ‘‘Yaṃ no satthā bhāsati, taṃ no sossāmā’’ti ādaragāravajātā mahantena ussāhena sotabbaṃ sampaṭicchitabbaṃ maññanti. Suppasannā pasādābhibuddhiyā vigatupakkilesatāya kallacittā muducittā honti. Pasannakāranti pasannehi kātabbasakkāraṃ, dhammāmisapūjanti attho. Tattha āmisapūjaṃ dassento ‘‘paṇītānī’’tiādimāha. Dhammapūjā pana ‘‘tathattāyā’’ti iminā dassitā. Tathābhāvāyāti yathattāya yassa vaṭṭadukkhanissaraṇatthāya dhammo desito, tathābhāvāya, tenāha ‘‘dhammānudhammapaṭipattipūraṇatthāyā’’ti. Sā ca dhammānudhammapaṭipatti yāya anupubbiyā paṭipajjitabbā, paṭipajjantānañca sati ajjhattikaṅgasamavāye ekaṃsikā tassā pāripūrīti taṃ anupubbiṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘keci saraṇesū’’tiādi vuttaṃ.
“住于此处的经文中”的意思是:站在阐明狮子吼作用圆满的经句——“已行道的人能成就”——之处。应综合起来理解:将这狮子吼视为不共的、不被他人在辩论中驳倒的、最殊胜的吼声、无有恐怖的吼声。此法同样适用于其余(狮子吼)。所谓“前十种”,是指从开头一直到“在解脱方面没有与我相等者”为止,这最初的十种狮子吼。在这里,简别处用了属格,因此他说“一一”等。而“并且在众中作吼”等是伴随的部分:当世尊发出“我看见某个苦行僧生于地狱”的狮子吼时,他在众中吼,无所畏惧地吼,直到“已行道的人能成就”,这样的意义连接是可能的。同样,这也适用于其余九种。显示巴利原文
Imasmiṃpanokāse ṭhatvāti ‘‘paṭipannā ca ārādhentī’’ti etasmiṃ sīhanādakiccapāripūridīpane pāḷipadese ṭhatvā. Samodhānetabbāti saṅkalitabbā. Eko sīhanādo asādhāraṇo aññehi appaṭivattiyo seṭṭhanādo abhītanādoti katvā. Esa nayo sesesupi. Purimānaṃ dasannantiādito paṭṭhāya yāva ‘‘vimuttiyā mayhaṃ sadiso natthī’’ti etesaṃ purimānaṃ dasannaṃ sīhanādānaṃ, niddhāraṇe cettha sāmivacanaṃ, tenāha ‘‘ekekassā’’ti. ‘‘Parisāsu ca nadatī’’ti ādayo parivārā ‘‘ekaccaṃ tapassiṃ niraye nibbattaṃ passāmī’’ti sīhanādaṃ nadanto bhagavā parisāyaṃ nadati visārado nadati yāva ‘‘paṭipannā ārādhentī’’ti atthayojanāya sambhavato . Tathā sesesupi navasu.
“如是”等,就是把前面所说过的那些总括起来展示。“这十种”就是指那些“并且在众中作吼”等狮子吼。“前十种”就是前面所说过的前十种狮子吼。依着眷属的方式分别配合,就成为一百种狮子吼。而如此配合时,前面的十种也这样算入,于是便有一百一十种狮子吼。“如此说者的论说”,是指那些这样宣说的外道之说。“予以破斥后”,就是通过显示那种情况不存在而加以否定之后。为了说明世尊曾在《优昙婆利咖经》中,面对尼拘陀游方者及其眷属,开示垢秽的分别与清净的分别,作了狮子吼:“在此,尼拘陀!苦行僧……”(《长部》3.33),所以现在说“今为展示在众中已曾作过的狮子吼”等。显示巴利原文
‘‘Eva’’ntiādi yathāvuttānaṃ tesaṃ saṅkaletvā dassanaṃ. Te dasāti te ‘‘parisāsu ca nadatī’’ti ādayo sīhanādā. Purimānaṃ dasannanti yathāvuttānaṃ purimānaṃ dasannaṃ. Parivāravasenāti paccekaṃ parivāravasena yojiyamānā sataṃ sīhanādā. Purimā ca dasāti tathā ayojiyamānā purimā ca dasāti evaṃ dasādhikaṃ sīhanādasataṃ hoti. Evaṃ vādīnaṃ vādanti evaṃ pavattavādānaṃ titthiyānaṃ vādaṃ. Paṭisedhetvāti tathābhāvābhāvadassanena paṭikkhipitvā. Yaṃ bhagavā udumbarikasutte ‘‘idha nigrodha tapassī’’tiādinā (dī. ni. 3.33) upakkilesavibhāgaṃ, pārisuddhivibhāgañca dassento saparisassa nigrodhassa paribbājakassa purato sīhanādaṃ nadi, taṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘idāni parisati naditapubbaṃ sīhanādaṃ dassento’’tiādi vuttaṃ.
【外道居留处论释】显示巴利原文
Titthiyaparivāsakathāvaṇṇanā
404 “Idanti(这话是指)”是指“于王舍城灵鹫山居住的我……问问题”这段话。实际上,当尼拘陀问问题、世尊回答他时,世尊并不住在灵鹫山,而是住在王舍城附近,然而经文却说“于王舍城灵鹫山居住的我”,这是因为当时他在灵鹫山的居住并未中断,因此说“彼世尊”等。“Yoge”意为“方法”,也就是出离苦的方法。显示巴利原文
404.Idanti ‘‘rājagahe gijjhakūṭe pabbate viharantaṃ maṃ…pe… pañhaṃ pucchī’’ti idaṃ vacanaṃ. Kāmaṃ yadā nigrodho pañhaṃ pucchi, bhagavā cassa vissajjesi, na tadā gijjhakūṭe pabbate viharati, rājagahasamīpe pana viharatīti katvā ‘‘rājagahe gijjhakūṭe pabbate viharantaṃ ma’’nti vuttaṃ, gijjhakūṭe viharaṇañcassa tadā avicchinnanti, tenāha ‘‘yaṃ taṃ bhagavā’’tiādi. Yogeti naye, dukkhanissaraṇūpāyeti attho.
405 “Yaṃ parivāsaṃ sāmaṇerabhūmiyaṃ ṭhito parivasatī”的文句连接是:处于沙弥阶位者所行的“别住”。因为只有处于沙弥阶位的人才需行别住,而非在家者,因此若未行别住便不能出家。“渴望出家,渴望具足戒”——然而这里“出家”一词的使用,只是为了文句通顺,正如《波逸提》第五十条中为通顺而使用“二夜”(dirattatirattaṃ sahaseyyaṃ)的说法一样。“入村等”:此“等”字涵盖:妓女、寡妇、粗大女、黄门、比丘尼的行境;对同梵行者各种杂务的机敏或懒惰等;对教示与询问等有强烈欲求;对从外道而来之人——当听闻其缺点及三宝功德时不悦,反之,依次听闻功德与缺点时却欢喜——应知这些即是彼之集合,故说“圆满八种行”。捶打、击打是为探究其内心,如同锻冶金子一般。显示巴利原文
405. Yaṃ parivāsaṃ sāmaṇerabhūmiyaṃ ṭhito parivasatīti yojanā. Yasmā sāmaṇerabhūmiyaṃ ṭhitena parivasitabbaṃ, na gihibhūtena, tasmā aparivasitvāyeva pabbajjaṃ labhati. Ākaṅkhati pabbajjaṃ, ākaṅkhati upasampadanti ettha pana pabbajjā-ggahaṇaṃ vacanasiliṭṭhatāvaseneva ‘‘dirattatirattaṃ sahaseyya’’nti (pāci. 50) ettha dirattaggahaṇaṃ viya. Gāmappavesanādīnīti ādi-saddena vesiyāvidhavāthullakumāripaṇḍakabhikkhunigocaratā, sabrahmacārīnaṃ uccāvacesu kiṃkaraṇīyesu dakkhānalasāditā, uddesaparipucchādīsu tibbachandatā, yassa titthāyatanato idhāgato, tassa avaṇṇe, ratanattayassa ca vaṇṇe anattamanatā, tadubhayaṃ yathākkamaṃ vaṇṇe ca avaṇṇe ca attamanatāti imesaṃ saṅgaho veditabbo, tenāha ‘‘aṭṭha vattāni pūrentenā’’ti. Ghaṃsitvā koṭṭetvāti ajjhāsayassa vīmaṃsanavasena suvaṇṇaṃ viya ghaṃsitvā koṭṭetvā.
“坐在僧众中间”:为了助成他,如同僧伽中的长老那样,在足数组成僧团的比丘众中坐下。“Vūpakaṭṭho”:远离。对于那样的人,戒清净中的“不放逸”是不言自明的,所以说“于业处不忘失念”。“Pesitacitto”:心倾向于涅槃,朝向涅槃,趣向涅槃,趋入涅槃。即使是出身高贵的善男子,也是具足行仪,为证阿拉汉果而期待出家的,因此将他们合称为“善男子们,即具足行仪的善男子们”,所以又说“正确地,即是以因、以缘”。正是基于“我已陷入生”等这样的理趣,此处所说的“正确地”,是指以悚惧感为先导、依教奉行的出家。“以因”:依正理。“达到”:到达、证得。“成就”:成就无学的戒、定、慧,或是圆满的意思。显示巴利原文
Gaṇamajjhe nisīditvāti upasampadākammassa gaṇappahonakānaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ majjhe saṅghatthero viya tassa anuggahatthaṃ nisīditvā. Vūpakaṭṭhoti vivitto. Tādisassa sīlavisodhane appamādo avuttasiddhoti āha ‘‘kammaṭṭhāne satiṃ avijahanto’’ti. Pesitacittoti nibbānaṃ pati pesitacitto taṃninno tappoṇo tappabbhāro. Jātikulaputtāpi ācārasampannā eva arahattādhigamāya pabbajjāpekkhā hontīti tepi tehi ekasaṅgahe karonto āha ‘‘kulaputtāti ācārakulaputtā’’ti, tenāha ‘‘sammadevāti hetunāva kāraṇenevā’’ti. ‘‘Otiṇṇomhi jātiyā’’tiādinā nayena hi saṃvegapubbikaṃ yathānusiṭṭhaṃ pabbajjaṃ sandhāya idha ‘‘sammadevā’’ti vuttaṃ. Hetunāti ñāyena. Pāpuṇitvāti patvā adhigantvā. Sampādetvāti asekkhā sīlasamādhipaññā nipphādetvā, paripūretvā vāti attho.
Niṭṭhāpetuṃ:以结语的方式作结束。因为正是以「梵行圆满……住」这一阿拉汉果的顶峰,结束了这次开示。而「然而另一位……成为了……」这一结语,则是法结集者们所说。至于这里面在义理上没有详细解释的部分,都是很容易理解的。显示巴利原文
Niṭṭhāpetunti nigamanavasena pariyosāpetuṃ. ‘‘Brahmacariyapariyosānaṃ…pe… vihāsī’’ti iminā eva hi arahattanikūṭena desanā pariyosāpitā. Taṃ pana nigamento ‘‘aññataro kho panā…pe… ahosī’’ti vuttaṃ dhammasaṅgāhakehi. Yaṃ panettha atthato na vibhattaṃ, taṃ suviññeyyameva.